Diary


2009-02-26 野菜を食べろ,というパターナリズム。

_ パターナリズムということばを最近よく耳にする。あまり好きなことばではないが,支持者も多いらしい。

たばこ総合研究センター〔TASC〕が編集・発行している雑誌『談』の最新号(no.83)が特集・パターナリズムと公共性,を組んでいる。まだ,しっかりとは読んでいないので,こちらの感想はあとまわしに。この雑誌のエディターとして辣腕をふるっている佐藤真さんの仕掛けたことなので,相当に期待はしているのだが,はたしてその内容たるやいかに。いずれ,ここでも取り上げて論じてみたいと思う。

それとは別に,ある友人が話してくれた日常のなかのパターナリズムについて,考えてみたい。

ある友人とは,40歳前後と思われる女性編集者。生来の野菜ぎらいで,ふだんはほとんど野菜を食べない,という。そういう話をすると,インテリの女性執筆者の多くは,ほぼ間違いなく,野菜を食べないとからだに悪い,と懇切丁寧にお説教をしてくださるのだ,と。しかも,場合によっては,一つひとつ数字まであげて,どの野菜にどのような栄養価があって,100グラムにつきどれだけの栄養素が含まれていて,人間のからだは一日にこれこれの量のこれこれの栄養素を摂取しなければならないのだ,とそれはそれは情熱をこめて説得にかかるそうである。なかには,万歩計で歩数を毎日はかって記録し,食べた食事の記録も数量化して,消費エネルギーと摂取栄養素との比較までしている人もいるとか。その上で過不足があれば,栄養補給のサプリメントを飲むそうな。そして,すべて,数字で表さないと気がすまない,とか。このぐらい気をつけていても,時折,風邪を引いてしまうから,貴女もちゃんとしなくちゃ駄目よ,という調子なそうな。

それに引き換え,女性編集者は,嫌いなものは食べない,もちろん,数量でからだの管理などはしない。しかも,その日に食べたいな,と思うものはどんどん食べる。つまり,からだが食べたがっているものはなんでも気が済むまで食べる。やや,肥満気味ではあるが,着痩せするので太っているとはだれも気づかない,とはご本人の弁。野菜を食べない代わりに,果物は大好きなのでいっぱい食べる,という。だから,これでいいんだ,と。しかも,よくよく聞いてみると,肉が食べたいなと思ったら,どんなふうに調理しようかと考える。たとえば,ピーマンと炒めて,唐がらしをいっぱい振りかけて食べたいと思ったら,ピーマンをいっぱい入れて炒める,という。滅多にこういうことはないけれども,食べたいお思ったときにはドッサリと食べるという。

そういう話をインテリの執筆者に話すと,そういうのを「わがまま放題というのだ」と叱られるそうな。毎日,満遍なく栄養のバランスを考えながら,きちんとした食生活を送ることが大事なのだから,必ず守らなくてはいけない,とこれまたお説教だそうな。でも,女性編集者は,かなり頻繁に健康診断をしてもらうことにしているが,医学的にはどこも異常はないし,体調もどこも悪くないし,風邪もほとんど引かない,という。でも,わたしのような食生活をしている人は少数派だから,いつも,みんなに総攻撃をくらってしまうが,間違っているでしょうか,と相談される。

そこで,わたしはどう答えたか。

インテリの執筆者のおっしゃることは,どこも間違ってはいません。だから,否定のしようがありません。まことに清く,正しく生活していらっしゃって,まさに世の鏡です。でも,ひとつだけ間違いがあります。それは,自分の正しいと信じている食生活を他者に押しつけることです。自分でひとり正しいと信じて,科学的な裏づけのもとに,自主管理することのできる人は立派です。だからといって,それを他者に押しつけるのは,わたしに言わせれば,こころのどこかに病的なものを感じてしまいます。自分のなかに,どこか,不安を感じている証拠です。ですから,みんな自分と同じようにすることを強要します。これが「パターナリズム」の原点だとわたしは考えています。つまり,正しいことをみんなに広めることは,正しい「公共性」を確保するために必要なのだ,と。

もちろん,これはほんの一例です。これと同じようなことが,もし,信仰の問題で強要されるとしたら,それは憲法違反です。信教の自由に反します。それでも,時折,街角で「折伏」と称するまじめな人びとに出会うことがあります。不幸にして,わたしは一度も,そういう人に声をかけられたことがない。一度だけ,こちらから声をかけて話をしたことがあります。10分くらい話をしたら,向こうさんが逃げて行ってしまいました。なぜでしょう。わたしが質問攻めにしたからです。その質問に答えられなくなってしまったから。そういう矛盾だらけの,善意の押し売りは,信仰だけではなく,もちろん食生活だけてもなく,日常生活のいたるところにころがっています。ですから,わたしは基本的にパターナリズムは嫌いです。

しかし,公共の倫理や道徳が乱れてくると,それをなんとかすべきだという議論が必ず持ち上がってきます。たしかに,多くの人びとに迷惑をかけるようなマナーの悪さは困ったものです。だから,なんとかそれを制止しようという人びとが現れます。これがパターナリズムを生み出す根拠の一つではあります。

ですから,そのあたりのバランスの取り方が問題なわけです。でも,権力はパターナリズムが大好きですから,ちょっと気を許すと,いつのまにやらがんじがらめにされてしまいます。その典型的なものが「法律」というパターナリズムです。

車のシートベルトはその典型例です。安全を守る,というこのこと自体はまったく正しい。しかし,それを法律で規制して全員にそれを強要することの意味はなにか,一度,よくよく考えてみてください。だれのための安全なのか,自分で管理すればいいだけの話,というのがわたしの考え。したくない人はしなくてもいい,と。でも,いまではしないと法律違反です。

医療の現場で,もはや健康状態にはもどれないことが明白で,余命いくばくもない人に人口呼吸器を取り付けたりして,延命措置をとるのも,一種のパターナリズムです。このあたりになると,議論が百出してくることになります。また,臓器移植の問題も同じです。

ついでに言っておけば,ドーピングの問題も同じです。

となってくると,パターナリズムの根はきわめて深いということに気づくはずです。だからこそ,みんなで議論する必要があろう,というのが佐藤真さんの企みなのでしょう。

さあ,いまの仕事に一区切りついたら,『談』の最新号を読むことにしよう。

本日のツッコミ(全83件) [ツッコミを入れる]
_ yxddsmy (2011-11-08 03:02)

EWYMlO <a href="http://weqpushxledg.com/">weqpushxledg</a>, [url=http://wpqodmgjfkpf.com/]wpqodmgjfkpf[/url], [link=http://hxacrqaovtwi.com/]hxacrqaovtwi[/link], http://spqstiqczoud.com/

_ zjdhroy (2011-12-16 07:59)

VuVVXs <a href="http://gzdnrdppreum.com/">gzdnrdppreum</a>, [url=http://iitefwjabbtx.com/]iitefwjabbtx[/url], [link=http://tzowcotqpxsi.com/]tzowcotqpxsi[/link], http://ikfrzhwyfueq.com/

_ viagra apoteket (2011-12-19 07:52)

c, 206237 http://refuge-moree.com generique cialis, http://the-varia-jun.com erekce, http://ferrarauno.info/ levitra, http://dasf.biz/ viagra, http://ingvildslykke.com/ viagra online, http://ikteroi.net/ cialis τιμη, http://temoignages.info/ achat viagra en ligne, http://direct-voyance.info viagra femme, http://construweb.net la viagra, http://metalalliance.org/ comprar cialis, http://hellahotline.com viagra kvinner, http://bali-swiss.com viagra für die frau kaufen, http://swucks.com/ viagra kaufen ohne rezept, http://refereekillers.com viagra, http://ideanm.com/ viagra wirkung, http://marcokokol.com/ viagra generika kaufen, http://pubbliroma.com/ cialis, http://zajezdy-levne.info viagra pro zeny, http://digiart49.com viagra, http://mettemolbak.com/ viagra, http://pujcky24.info/ viagra cena, http://stereen.com/ cialis billigt,

_ luonnon viagra (2011-12-19 14:00)

e, 206237 http://refuge-moree.com cialis, http://the-varia-jun.com viagra, http://maaritinliikuntahyvinvointi.com/ cialis hinta apteekki, http://ferrarauno.info/ viagra effetti collaterali, http://dasf.biz/ cialis, http://moscoweb.com/ acheter viagra en ligne, http://ingvildslykke.com/ viagra reseptfritt, http://ikteroi.net/ ΕΔ, http://vesperia.net/ viagra, http://temoignages.info/ viagra, http://flatmud.net/ ΕΔ, http://maxi-perf.com viagra prix, http://wtfdexter.com/ cialis, http://construweb.net viagra, http://bali-swiss.com viagra rezept,, http://rapnacional.info/ viagra, http://refereekillers.com viagra, http://miccopesonenmiccopesonen.com/ viagra hinta, http://pubbliroma.com/ cialis vendita, http://thedailywoofer.com/ viagra, http://digiart49.com viagra bestellen, http://stereen.com/ cialis, http://pujcky24.info/ viagra online,

_ viagra (2011-12-19 20:14)

a, 206237 http://pujcky-nebankovni-online.info/ cialis koupit, http://maaritinliikuntahyvinvointi.com/ cialis hinta, http://vesperia.net/ pharmacie en ligne viagra, http://splatscreen.com/ viagra, http://direct-voyance.info viagra effets secondaires, http://amb-young.com/ viagra ohne rezept kaufen, http://flatmud.net/ viagra.com, http://construweb.net viagra, http://affittarecase.com cialis, http://viajecicosporelmundo.com comprar cialis online, http://bali-swiss.com viagra, http://rapnacional.info/ viagra e prozac, http://swucks.com/ viagra, http://refereekillers.com blue pill, http://acmagazine.net viagra femminile, http://thedailywoofer.com/ viagra bestellen zonder recept, http://mettemolbak.com/ cialis, http://digiart49.com online apotheke, http://stereen.com/ kamagra, http://pujcky24.info/ viagra pro zeny,

_ cialis (2011-12-20 02:22)

f, 206237 http://pokemonpalast.com viagra, http://the-varia-jun.com prodej viagra, http://ferrarauno.info/ vendita viagra, http://dasf.biz/ viagra bivirkninger, http://ingvildslykke.com/ viagra, http://ikteroi.net/ αγορα cialis, http://vesperia.net/ achat viagra, http://temoignages.info/ sildenafil, http://direct-voyance.info acheter viagra, http://metalalliance.org/ cialis, http://affittarecase.com cialis effetti, http://petit-stargate.com/ cialis pas cher, http://hellahotline.com kjøpe viagra norge, http://refereekillers.com viagra, http://marcokokol.com/ viagra bestellen rezeptfrei, http://acmagazine.net viagra, http://pubbliroma.com/ cialis, http://mettemolbak.com/ cialis viagra, http://stereen.com/ cialis fass, http://pujcky24.info/ levitra, http://sonorabienesraices.com/ viagra,

_ viagra (2011-12-20 08:32)

b, 206237 http://refuge-moree.com generique cialis, http://ikteroi.net/ cialis fed ex, http://temoignages.info/ viagra, http://direct-voyance.info viagra, http://flatmud.net/ ΕΔ, http://amb-young.com/ viagra, http://ansee.net/ バイアグラ, http://maxi-perf.com acheter viagra, http://wtfdexter.com/ cialis viagra, http://metalalliance.org/ cialis, http://affittarecase.com cialis, http://rapnacional.info/ viagra feminino onde comprar, http://miccopesonenmiccopesonen.com/ viagra, http://acmagazine.net viagra vendita, http://pubbliroma.com/ acquistare cialis online, http://thedailywoofer.com/ viagra bijwerkingen, http://zajezdy-levne.info viagra bez receptu, http://stereen.com/ cialis tadalis,

_ achat cialis en ligne (2011-12-20 14:56)

c, 206237 http://refuge-moree.com achat cialis, http://maaritinliikuntahyvinvointi.com/ viagra,, http://splatscreen.com/ billigt viagra, http://temoignages.info/ achat viagra en ligne, http://affittarecase.com comprare cialis, http://petit-stargate.com/ cialis, http://refereekillers.com viagra, http://miccopesonenmiccopesonen.com/ viagra netista, http://digiart49.com viagra, http://mettemolbak.com/ viagra, http://pujcky24.info/ cialis, http://stereen.com/ generisk cialis, http://sonorabienesraices.com/ viagra,

_ sildenafil (2011-12-20 21:27)

c, 206237 http://pujcky-nebankovni-online.info/ cialis online, http://the-varia-jun.com viagra, http://refuge-moree.com cialis, http://ferrarauno.info/ viagra acquistare, http://dasf.biz/ viagra til kvinder,, http://ingvildslykke.com/ viagra for kvinner, http://moscoweb.com/ achat viagra en ligne, http://ikteroi.net/ αγορα cialis, http://splatscreen.com/ viagra biverkningar, http://ansee.net/ viagra overnight cheap, http://construweb.net viagra precio farmacia, http://affittarecase.com cialis effetti, http://petit-stargate.com/ comparateur prix cialis, http://hellahotline.com viagra reseptfritt, http://bali-swiss.com viagra ohne rezept, http://rapnacional.info/ viagra bula, http://refereekillers.com viagra, http://miccopesonenmiccopesonen.com/ viagraa virosta, http://acmagazine.net cialis, http://thedailywoofer.com/ viagra, http://zajezdy-levne.info buy viagra, http://mettemolbak.com/ buy viagra, http://pujcky24.info/ viagra cialis, http://starflamcelinequebec.com cialis,

_ prix du medicament cialis (2011-12-21 04:17)

b, 206237 http://the-varia-jun.com buy viagra, http://maaritinliikuntahyvinvointi.com/ cialis levitra, http://moscoweb.com/ viagra, http://ikteroi.net/ παρενεργειες cialis, http://vesperia.net/ viagra pour homme, http://direct-voyance.info viagra generique france, http://ansee.net/ viagra for women, http://wtfdexter.com/ viagra køb, http://viajecicosporelmundo.com comprar cialis generico, http://bali-swiss.com viagra generika kaufen, http://petit-stargate.com/ acheter cialis, http://acmagazine.net viagra femminile, http://thedailywoofer.com/ viagra,

_ order cialis online (2011-12-22 13:18)

d, 206237 http://easyfreeps3.com/index.html viagra.com, http://silviamariana.com/index.html cheap levitra, http://duspacollective.org/index.html cialis levitra viagra, http://bismanrollerderby.com/index.html cheap viagra, http://fresh2009.org/index.html viagra online order, http://totallyclubpenguin.com/index.html cialis for sale, http://kuchipudivaibhavam.org/index.html _effets secondaires de levitra, http://unwindbeverage.net/index.html pharmacy viagra, http://busrev.com/index.html cialis, http://772media.com/index.html cialis online, http://degrassisplash.com/index.html buy tadalafil cialis, http://tmrgolf.com/index.html compare levitra viagra, http://studiofiveshowroom.com/index.html levitra 90 pills, http://switchesmusic.net/index.html viagra,

_ levitra vs viagra (2011-12-22 20:25)

d, 206237 http://easyfreeps3.com/index.html cheap viagra, http://silviamariana.com/index.html cialis levitra, http://duspacollective.org/index.html cialis soft tabs, http://bismanrollerderby.com/index.html viagra price, http://fresh2009.org/index.html uk viagra, http://kuchipudivaibhavam.org/index.html buy levitra, http://totallyclubpenguin.com/index.html cialis.com, http://unwindbeverage.net/index.html silagra generic viagra, http://busrev.com/index.html cialis, http://772media.com/index.html cialis levitra viagra vs, http://degrassisplash.com/index.html pharmacy cialis buy, http://tmrgolf.com/index.html levitra vardenafil, http://studiofiveshowroom.com/index.html levitra.com, http://switchesmusic.net/index.html viagra plus 90 pills,

_ cialis 2 doses (2011-12-23 03:47)

e, 206237 http://easyfreeps3.com/index.html viagra on line, http://silviamariana.com/index.html levitra levitra, http://duspacollective.org/index.html cialis 4 pills, http://bismanrollerderby.com/index.html viagra, http://fresh2009.org/index.html online viagra, http://kuchipudivaibhavam.org/index.html cialis comparison levitra viagra, http://totallyclubpenguin.com/index.html viagra cialis levitra, http://unwindbeverage.net/index.html cheap viagra, http://busrev.com/index.html cialis 90 pills, http://772media.com/index.html cialis, http://degrassisplash.com/index.html online rx cialis, http://tmrgolf.com/index.html will byetta block levitra, http://studiofiveshowroom.com/index.html levitra 4 pills, http://switchesmusic.net/index.html viagra dosages,

_ levitra online (2011-12-23 10:47)

e, 206237 http://easyfreeps3.com/index.html erection viagra, http://silviamariana.com/index.html cheap levitra, http://duspacollective.org/index.html cialis 5mg cheap, http://bismanrollerderby.com/index.html low cost viagra, http://fresh2009.org/index.html viagra canada, http://kuchipudivaibhavam.org/index.html cialis generic levitra viagra, http://totallyclubpenguin.com/index.html cialis comment info personal remember, http://unwindbeverage.net/index.html viagra, http://772media.com/index.html cialis generic, http://busrev.com/index.html cialis generic capsule, http://degrassisplash.com/index.html cheap cialis, http://studiofiveshowroom.com/index.html levitra lady, http://tmrgolf.com/index.html levitra, http://switchesmusic.net/index.html viagra 60 pills,

_ generic viagra levitra and tadalafil (2011-12-24 01:13)

c, 206237 http://easyfreeps3.com/index.html viagra best buy, http://silviamariana.com/index.html levitra viagra abuse, http://duspacollective.org/index.html cialis, http://bismanrollerderby.com/index.html generic viagra, http://fresh2009.org/index.html order viagra, http://kuchipudivaibhavam.org/index.html levitra, http://totallyclubpenguin.com/index.html cialis super active 20 mg, http://unwindbeverage.net/index.html viagra online rx, http://772media.com/index.html cialis western open ticket, http://busrev.com/index.html buy cialis line, http://degrassisplash.com/index.html cialis online no, http://tmrgolf.com/index.html buy levitra viagra, http://studiofiveshowroom.com/index.html levitra 2 pills, http://switchesmusic.net/index.html discount viagra,

_ mail order levitra (2011-12-24 08:25)

c, 206237 http://easyfreeps3.com/index.html order viagra, http://silviamariana.com/index.html levitra.com, http://duspacollective.org/index.html cialis 120 pills, http://bismanrollerderby.com/index.html discount viagra overnight, http://fresh2009.org/index.html order viagra, http://totallyclubpenguin.com/index.html cialis cialis cialis genuinerx.net viagra, http://kuchipudivaibhavam.org/index.html buy levitra online, http://unwindbeverage.net/index.html discount viagra, http://772media.com/index.html cialis cialis genuinerx.net, http://busrev.com/index.html generic cialis, http://degrassisplash.com/index.html cialis, http://studiofiveshowroom.com/index.html levitra and grapefruit juice, http://tmrgolf.com/index.html vardenafil, http://switchesmusic.net/index.html uk viagra,

_ viagra (2011-12-24 15:37)

b, 206237 http://easyfreeps3.com/index.html viagra.com, http://silviamariana.com/index.html levitra, http://duspacollective.org/index.html cialis, http://bismanrollerderby.com/index.html viagra soft tabs 10 pills, http://fresh2009.org/index.html similar to viagra, http://kuchipudivaibhavam.org/index.html levitra 90 pills, http://totallyclubpenguin.com/index.html cheap cialis, http://unwindbeverage.net/index.html buy online viagra, http://busrev.com/index.html cialis 20 mg, http://772media.com/index.html cialis, http://degrassisplash.com/index.html cialis physical dependency, http://studiofiveshowroom.com/index.html levitra plus 400mg, http://tmrgolf.com/index.html buy levitra viagra, http://switchesmusic.net/index.html cost low viagra,

_ levitra side effects (2011-12-24 22:57)

b, 206237 http://easyfreeps3.com/index.html viagra online, http://silviamariana.com/index.html levitra 30 pills, http://duspacollective.org/index.html cialis online discount, http://bismanrollerderby.com/index.html viagra.com, http://fresh2009.org/index.html generic viagra, http://kuchipudivaibhavam.org/index.html cheap levitra, http://totallyclubpenguin.com/index.html cialis generic levitra viagra, http://unwindbeverage.net/index.html viagra for sale, http://772media.com/index.html cialis mg size, http://busrev.com/index.html cheap cialis sale online, http://degrassisplash.com/index.html cialis, http://tmrgolf.com/index.html levitra 20 pills, http://studiofiveshowroom.com/index.html actress in levitra commercial, http://switchesmusic.net/index.html viagra,

_ lrxxcpxnw (2011-12-26 07:03)

8SmG9U <a href="http://btumduyqflvu.com/">btumduyqflvu</a>, [url=http://xhjetkljyekn.com/]xhjetkljyekn[/url], [link=http://njipfnryvdgd.com/]njipfnryvdgd[/link], http://eezfmrulylbe.com/

_ will byetta block levitra (2011-12-28 17:54)

f, 206237 http://easyfreeps3.com/index.html cheap viagra, http://silviamariana.com/index.html levitra.com, http://duspacollective.org/index.html cialis, http://bismanrollerderby.com/index.html viagra 100 mg, http://fresh2009.org/index.html viagra for sale, http://kuchipudivaibhavam.org/index.html levitra generic cialis, http://totallyclubpenguin.com/index.html by cialis comment powered uri wordpress, http://unwindbeverage.net/index.html viagra oral jelly, http://772media.com/index.html order cialis, http://busrev.com/index.html cialis, http://degrassisplash.com/index.html cialis on line, http://studiofiveshowroom.com/index.html levitra, http://tmrgolf.com/index.html levitra, http://switchesmusic.net/index.html viagra pfizer buy,

_ generic viagra (2011-12-29 13:29)

c, 206237 http://easyfreeps3.com/index.html viagra, http://silviamariana.com/index.html levitra, http://duspacollective.org/index.html cialis uk, http://bismanrollerderby.com/index.html viagra, http://fresh2009.org/index.html viagra online store, http://totallyclubpenguin.com/index.html cialis, http://kuchipudivaibhavam.org/index.html levitra.com,, http://unwindbeverage.net/index.html viagra, http://busrev.com/index.html cheap cialis sale online, http://772media.com/index.html cialis sample pack, http://degrassisplash.com/index.html order cialis, http://tmrgolf.com/index.html buy levitra online, http://studiofiveshowroom.com/index.html levitra, http://switchesmusic.net/index.html buy viagra online,

_ cialis super active 10 pills (2011-12-30 09:42)

f, 206237 http://easyfreeps3.com/index.html cheap viagra, http://silviamariana.com/index.html buy levitra, http://duspacollective.org/index.html cialis generic, http://bismanrollerderby.com/index.html viagra, http://fresh2009.org/index.html order viagra, http://kuchipudivaibhavam.org/index.html levitra, http://totallyclubpenguin.com/index.html cialis, http://unwindbeverage.net/index.html usa pharmacy viagra, http://772media.com/index.html order cialis, http://busrev.com/index.html cialis mg purchase, http://degrassisplash.com/index.html cialis, http://studiofiveshowroom.com/index.html levitra 2003 latest, http://tmrgolf.com/index.html cialis compare levitra viagra, http://switchesmusic.net/index.html viagra,

_ pqxethdryma (2012-01-28 05:22)

Gmr1su <a href="http://isodxdezjprx.com/">isodxdezjprx</a>, [url=http://vukebkthaqud.com/]vukebkthaqud[/url], [link=http://klaqmrmyoncm.com/]klaqmrmyoncm[/link], http://tvuxkfjbnxjp.com/

_ Huyghdsfiuhs (2012-02-01 04:35)

http://www.buyvaltrexonlineshop.com#70303 valtrex buy uk - can you buy valtrex online

_ Asggsffjhgsjhg (2012-02-01 20:57)

http://www.discountmedicationpharm.com#50854 online pharmacy no prescription canada - discount medication online australia

_ Kemxitnvd (2012-02-02 21:32)

http://www.buyclomidsite.com#958299210 buy clomid with paypal - buy clomid pills

_ Ozlakujijhdfgf (2012-02-03 03:28)

http://www.bestdiazepamsite.com#71430 generic valium online - buy valium online cheapest

_ Tzabsjhisdd (2012-02-04 07:27)

http://www.cheapdiazepamprices.com#94810 valium online buy ireland - where to buy valium online

_ Jopwesfssfsdfg (2012-02-04 09:53)

http://buyonlineisotretinoin.com/#57006 buy accutane canada online - buy accutane turkey

_ prednisone (2012-02-04 22:48)

c, http://mom2sarahjo.com/valtrex.html valtrex valacyclovir, http://1merchantaccount.info/prednisone.html prednisone, http://haejinyoon.com/cytotec.html how to use cytotec for an abortion, http://uncertainratio.com/glucophage.html glucophage.com, http://waterwiseirrigation.org/propecia.html to buy propecia, http://karenkuhlman.com/glucophage.html phentermine and glucophage, http://rmprocess.com/bactrim.html bactrim, http://haejinyoon.com/erythromycin.html erythromycin 60 pills, http://uncertainratio.com/cipro.html cipro antibiotic side effects, http://my-projectorrental.info/celexa.html ultram and celexa together, http://garagesalechasers.com/antabuse.html 500 antabuse cheap generic mg, http://tandystevens.net/furosemide.html furosemide, http://garagesalechasers.com/zoloft.html symptoms of zoloft, http://texaspecangrowersalliance.org/tetracycline.html sumycin 500, http://mandmteamproductions.com/celebrex.html order celebrex online, http://uncertainratio.com/viagra.html viagra, http://wmspawprints.com/cymbalta.html cymbalta and alcohol, http://givebackchicago.com/inderal.html inderal withdrawal, http://slipcoveredsofas.org/diamox.html apo-acetazolamide, http://greennetblog.com/nolvadex.html nolvadex-d, http://getrealfunky.com/plavix.html cheap plavix,

_ Buteredkjskjdf (2012-02-06 10:52)

http://www.buy-xenicalonline.com/#25602 buy xenical online free shipping - order xenical diet pills online

_ Ddfdfgfsfufgfg (2012-02-07 01:19)

http://buyonlinediflucan.com/#32230 generic diflucan used - what does generic diflucan look like

_ levitra (2012-02-07 03:25)

c, http://dtlagalleries.com/index.html retin-a, http://diet-clinic.net/index.html acomplia loss weight, http://besthealthdrugs.com/index.html celebrex, http://wmh-pres.org/index.html plavix and side effects, http://ledietreviews.com/index.html order erythromycin, http://kamergids.com/index.html buy plavix, http://benitur.com/index.html cialis for sale, http://nmra75.org/index.html clomid progesterone, http://mariapiamalerba.com/index.html cafergot, http://msford.com/index.html prednisolone prednisone, http://gothamrally.org/index.html cipro,

_ order acomplia (2012-02-07 04:22)

d, http://smokefreecanadaclinics.com/index.html elimite, http://atsmedical.info/index.html generic seroquel, http://gokuldashearthospital.com/index.html cialis.com, http://aromatherapy-oils-wholesale.com/index.html acomplia + medication, http://nmra75.org/index.html clomid,

_ zyprexa seroquel (2012-02-07 04:23)

d, http://vitaschaferhundklubben.com/index.html levitra plus 400mg, http://low-carb-diets-online.info/index.html acomplia in usa, http://smokefreecanadaclinics.com/index.html elimite on sale, http://gokuldashearthospital.com/index.html cialis comment info personal remember, http://drug-rehab-clinic.com/index.html cialis 2 pills, http://mynoblearts.com/index.html buy propecia online, http://laborlaw-posters.com/index.html antabuse disulfiram, http://envirolinkuk.org/index.html discount purchase zithromax, http://williamstull.com/index.html female version of viagra, http://drquclinic.com/index.html order viagra, http://siouxvalleyvetclinic.com/index.html levitra 10 mg, http://newluna.com/index.html viagra, http://msford.com/index.html prednisolone, http://clinicascorpoemente.com/index.html clomid and multiple,

_ Czahgsyyhg (2012-02-07 05:23)

http://www.buyingxanaxnow.com#24435 buy xanax mastercard - buy xanax safe

_ order cialis (2012-02-07 07:17)

a, http://bostonhomeadvisors.com/index.html viagra.com, http://laborlaw-posters.com/index.html order antabuse, http://envirolinkuk.org/index.html zithromax pak, http://addtreatmentcenters.net/index.html cialis 2 pills, http://bladdercontrolmedicines.info/index.html what is ciprofloxacin,

_ Czahgdyhg (2012-02-07 07:30)

http://www.ci-sun.com#82560 buy generic cialis store - buy cialis in london

_ viagra (2012-02-07 08:14)

c, http://dtlagalleries.com/index.html retin a purpose, http://smokefreecanadaclinics.com/index.html pravachol nasacort elimite, http://ledietreviews.com/index.html effects erythromycin side, http://patchworkvetclinic.com/index.html celebrex generic, http://laborlaw-posters.com/index.html antabuse side effects, http://lgbtiq.net/index.html seroquel weight loss, http://aromatherapyoilburners.info/index.html effects prednisolone side, http://policlinicsanmartin.com/index.html plavix and prilosec warning, http://askalternativemedicine.com/index.html antabuse 500 mg, http://williamstull.com/index.html non prescription viagra, http://best-treatment-for-hemorrhoids.net/index.html diflucan and breastfeeding, http://nmra75.org/index.html clomifene, http://bladdercontrolmedicines.info/index.html online cipro,

_ clomid 25 mg (2012-02-07 08:14)

e, http://dtlagalleries.com/index.html retin a acne treatment, http://porthadlockchamber.org/index.html retin-a, http://purduecea.org/index.html zithromax z pack, http://wmh-pres.org/index.html plavix blood pressure, http://eastsidehobnob.com/index.html diflucan infection yeast, http://laborlaw-posters.com/index.html 250 antabuse cheap generic mg online order, http://muinosmedicalvisuals.com/index.html buy tadalafil cialis, http://msford.com/index.html side effects of prednisolone, http://hebigroup.net/index.html tetracycline, http://robbiesrants.com/index.html cialis,

_ cialis (2012-02-07 08:19)

b, http://purduecea.org/index.html azithromycin zithromax, http://clinicaldatacr.com/index.html internet pharmacy propecia soma zoloft, http://chaordicedge.com/index.html acomplia drug name, http://allamericanrealtygroup.org/index.html cheap cialis, http://treatment-for-herpes.org/index.html prednisolone prednisone,

_ Czahfddgsjhg (2012-02-07 09:08)

http://www.buylevitranorthamerican.com#35973 buy levitra viagra - generic levitra buy

_ Tbapsemf (2012-02-07 12:24)

http://www.sitebuypropecia.com#204931135 buy propecia 1mg online - buy propecia online cheap pharmacy

_ Huydfttyhhjjsfiuhs (2012-02-07 13:22)

http://buyonlinediflucan.com/#20637 generic diflucan free shipping - buy diflucan uk

_ Czahtdgsjgffhg (2012-02-08 00:43)

http://www.shoplexaproonline.com#53434 lexapro side effects hair loss - lexapro 5 mg tablets

_ Nfsderfdfgfgrsder (2012-02-08 04:02)

http://www.buyonlinecipro.com/#71117 cipro online purchase - cipro generic equivalent http://buy-onlinepropecia.com/#52690 propecia generic patent - get propecia prescription

_ подушки для детей (2012-02-08 05:27)

c, http://dzelenin.com/ детское постельное белье,

_ borbo плед (2012-02-08 05:36)

f, http://dzelenin.com/ склад постельного белья в москве,

_ уютный плед (2012-02-08 06:22)

b, http://dzelenin.com/ постельное белье италия,

_ одеяло для новорожденного (2012-02-08 06:29)

d, http://dzelenin.com/poduski.html подушка хонда,

_ lasix side effects (2012-02-08 09:16)

f, http://www.ewats.info/2011_01_01_archive.html cheap lasix, http://alisonmcg.com/ levitra lady, http://www.ewats.info/2011_03_01_archive.html medtronic baclofen pump, http://bunche.org/index.php?option=com_frontpage&Itemid=1 order antabuse, http://www.ewats.info/p/calendar.html cytotec medicine,

_ accutane (2012-02-08 09:27)

f, http://www.ewats.info/2011_01_01_archive.html apo-furosemide, http://bunche.org/ atlanta accutane claims, http://www.ewats.info/2011_03_01_archive.html baclofen dosage, http://deiupcra.com/cart levitra and alpha blockers, http://chunkdout.com/ levitra generic cialis, http://www.ewats.info/2010_12_01_archive.html plavix guidelines, http://deiupcra.com/ viagra and phentermine,

_ 500 antabuse buy mg (2012-02-08 10:15)

f, http://www.ewats.info/2011_01_01_archive.html lasix surgery, http://alisonmcg.com/ levitra and zoloft, http://bunche.org/ buy accutane, http://www.ewats.info/2011_03_01_archive.html baclofen.com, http://deiupcra.com/cart cialis levitra vs, http://chunkdout.com/ cialis 20mg, http://www.ewats.info/2010_12_01_archive.html plavix, http://deiupcra.com/retailers cialis, http://www.ewats.info/ nolvadex,

_ nolvadex for man (2012-02-08 10:19)

d, http://www.ewats.info/2011_01_01_archive.html book dosage, http://alisonmcg.com/ _effets secondaires de levitra, http://www.ewats.info/p/contact.html order diflucan, http://chunkdout.com/ canada cialis, http://deiupcra.com/cart description of levitra, http://www.ewats.info/2010_12_01_archive.html plavix, http://deiupcra.com/retailers generic cialis tadalafil,

_ levitra (2012-02-08 10:21)

b, http://alisonmcg.com/ levitra, http://www.ewats.info/p/contact.html diflucan, http://deiupcra.com/cart buy cheap levitra, http://www.ewats.info/2010_12_01_archive.html plavix alternative generic, http://bunche.org/index.php?option=com_frontpage&Itemid=1 antabuse disulfiram, http://deiupcra.com/retailers cialis on line, http://deiupcra.com/ viagra, http://www.ewats.info/p/calendar.html cytotec, http://www.ewats.info/ liquid nolvadex,

_ abortion cytotec (2012-02-08 13:16)

d, http://alisonmcg.com/ levitra, http://bunche.org/ accutane.com, http://deiupcra.com/cart order levitra, http://chunkdout.com/ cheap cialis, http://www.ewats.info/2010_12_01_archive.html plavix, http://deiupcra.com/retailers cialis levitra viagra vs vs, http://www.ewats.info/ nolvadex,

_ baclofen (2012-02-08 13:26)

b, http://www.ewats.info/2011_01_01_archive.html lasix side effects, http://alisonmcg.com/ levitra lady, http://www.ewats.info/2011_03_01_archive.html baclofen effects side, http://www.ewats.info/p/contact.html diflucan and man, http://www.ewats.info/2010_12_01_archive.html plavix, http://bunche.org/index.php?option=com_frontpage&Itemid=1 antabuse precaution, http://www.ewats.info/p/calendar.html cytotec, http://www.ewats.info/ nolvadex.com,

_ Ogaydfjhuhdj (2012-02-08 13:48)

http://www.ci-sun.com#54273 buy cialis arizona - buy cialis germany

_ diflucan (2012-02-08 14:16)

e, http://www.ewats.info/2011_01_01_archive.html lasix taking, http://bunche.org/ accutane, http://www.ewats.info/2011_03_01_archive.html baclofen, http://chunkdout.com/ cialis, http://deiupcra.com/cart levitra, http://www.ewats.info/2010_12_01_archive.html plavix,

_ buy cialis poland (2012-02-08 14:22)

d, http://www.ewats.info/2011_01_01_archive.html k lasix micro, http://alisonmcg.com/ levitra generic cialis, http://chunkdout.com/ keywords cialis vardenafil, http://www.ewats.info/2010_12_01_archive.html plavix online, http://deiupcra.com/ viagra for woman, http://www.ewats.info/ nolvadex steroid,

_ joke viagra (2012-02-08 14:24)

e, http://www.ewats.info/2011_01_01_archive.html lasix, http://www.ewats.info/2011_03_01_archive.html baclofen, http://www.ewats.info/p/contact.html diflucan for nail fungus, http://chunkdout.com/ cialis physical dependency, http://www.ewats.info/2010_12_01_archive.html medication plavix, http://bunche.org/index.php?option=com_frontpage&Itemid=1 alcoholism antabuse medication, http://www.ewats.info/p/calendar.html cytotech, http://www.ewats.info/ buy nolvadex online,

_ levitra lady (2012-02-08 17:18)

d, http://www.ewats.info/2011_01_01_archive.html lasix danger, http://alisonmcg.com/ levitra, http://bunche.org/ how does accutane work, http://www.ewats.info/2011_03_01_archive.html baclofen dosage, http://chunkdout.com/ propecia cialis cialis, http://deiupcra.com/cart levitra, http://bunche.org/index.php?option=com_frontpage&Itemid=1 antabuse precaution, http://deiupcra.com/retailers cialis super active 30 pills, http://www.ewats.info/p/calendar.html cytotec 100 mg,

_ viagra for woman (2012-02-08 17:21)

d, http://www.ewats.info/2011_01_01_archive.html lasix renogram, http://alisonmcg.com/ levitra.com, http://www.ewats.info/p/contact.html diflucan, http://deiupcra.com/cart levitra 20 mg, http://www.ewats.info/2010_12_01_archive.html plavix, http://bunche.org/index.php?option=com_frontpage&Itemid=1 antabuse 500 mg, http://deiupcra.com/retailers cialis bloody nose,

_ cheap cialis (2012-02-08 18:09)

e, http://alisonmcg.com/ cheap levitra, http://www.ewats.info/p/contact.html buy diflucan, http://chunkdout.com/ cialis, http://www.ewats.info/2010_12_01_archive.html plavix and stents, http://deiupcra.com/retailers cialis.com, http://www.ewats.info/p/calendar.html cytotec, http://www.ewats.info/ cheap nolvadex,

_ keywords cialis vardenafil (2012-02-08 18:09)

c, http://www.ewats.info/2011_01_01_archive.html furoside, http://alisonmcg.com/ levitra.com, http://bunche.org/ buy accutane, http://www.ewats.info/2011_03_01_archive.html baclofen side effects, http://www.ewats.info/p/contact.html affect diflucan side, http://deiupcra.com/cart levitra vardenafil, http://bunche.org/index.php?option=com_frontpage&Itemid=1 250 antabuse generic mg, http://www.ewats.info/p/calendar.html pastillas cytotec, http://www.ewats.info/ nolvadex steroid,

_ cheap antabuse (2012-02-08 18:17)

b, http://www.ewats.info/2011_01_01_archive.html lasix dosage, http://alisonmcg.com/ levitra, http://www.ewats.info/2011_03_01_archive.html baclofen use, http://www.ewats.info/2010_12_01_archive.html plavix, http://deiupcra.com/retailers buy cialis without, http://bunche.org/index.php?option=com_frontpage&Itemid=1 antabuse alcohol, http://www.ewats.info/ nolvadex clomid,

_ Nepdawlicy (2012-02-08 20:22)

http://www.buycelebrex-cheap.com#171837028 order cheap celebrex - ordering celebrex over the counter

_ viagra online mozilla (2012-02-08 21:12)

b, http://www.ewats.info/2011_01_01_archive.html lasix and connecticut, http://www.ewats.info/p/contact.html diflucan medicine, http://chunkdout.com/ online store cialis, http://deiupcra.com/cart buy levitra, http://deiupcra.com/ viagra 360 pills, http://www.ewats.info/p/calendar.html cytotechnology,

_ cialis bloody nose (2012-02-08 21:22)

f, http://www.ewats.info/2011_03_01_archive.html 2blioresal baclofen, http://www.ewats.info/p/contact.html diflucan, http://chunkdout.com/ cialis pills generic, http://deiupcra.com/cart levitra, http://www.ewats.info/2010_12_01_archive.html plavix, http://deiupcra.com/retailers cialis 20 pills, http://bunche.org/index.php?option=com_frontpage&Itemid=1 disulfiram, http://www.ewats.info/p/calendar.html buy cytotec, http://www.ewats.info/ buy chemical citrate nolvadex research tamoxifen,

_ Domaderloxas (2012-02-08 21:23)

http://buy-onlinepropecia.com/#61610 buy propecia 90 - buy cheap propecia uk http://www.buyonlinecipro.com/#99624 cipro cheap online - generic ciprodex

_ diflucan (2012-02-08 22:10)

f, http://www.ewats.info/2011_01_01_archive.html injectible lasix order, http://alisonmcg.com/ levitra, http://www.ewats.info/p/contact.html diflucan, http://chunkdout.com/ cialis online, http://www.ewats.info/2010_12_01_archive.html plavix, http://deiupcra.com/ order viagra, http://www.ewats.info/p/calendar.html cytotec, http://www.ewats.info/ nolvadex.com,

_ antabuse tablet (2012-02-08 22:11)

a, http://alisonmcg.com/ levitra.com, http://deiupcra.com/cart vardenafil levitra, http://chunkdout.com/ discount cialis, http://www.ewats.info/2010_12_01_archive.html plavix drug interactions, http://deiupcra.com/ cheap viagra,

_ plavix pattent expire (2012-02-09 01:14)

a, http://www.ewats.info/p/contact.html diflucan, http://chunkdout.com/ but cialis cheap, http://deiupcra.com/cart actress in levitra commercial, http://www.ewats.info/2010_12_01_archive.html plavix online, http://bunche.org/index.php?option=com_frontpage&Itemid=1 antabus, http://www.ewats.info/p/calendar.html cytotechnology program, http://www.ewats.info/ apo-tamox,

_ nebulized lasix (2012-02-09 01:23)

b, http://alisonmcg.com/ levitra 30 pills, http://www.ewats.info/2011_03_01_archive.html intrathecal baclofen, http://www.ewats.info/p/contact.html 20six.co.uk diflucan link, http://deiupcra.com/cart levitra online, http://www.ewats.info/2010_12_01_archive.html plavix.com, http://bunche.org/index.php?option=com_frontpage&Itemid=1 antabuse liver, http://deiupcra.com/retailers buy cialis, http://deiupcra.com/ buy generic viagra, http://www.ewats.info/ nolvadex,

_ cialis (2012-02-09 02:13)

c, http://alisonmcg.com/ levitra, http://bunche.org/ accutane online, http://www.ewats.info/2011_03_01_archive.html lioresal, http://www.ewats.info/2010_12_01_archive.html plavix and mouth ulcers, http://bunche.org/index.php?option=com_frontpage&Itemid=1 antabuse 30 pills, http://deiupcra.com/retailers cialis, http://www.ewats.info/p/calendar.html cytotec induction,

_ buy levitra online (2012-02-09 02:25)

b, http://www.ewats.info/2011_01_01_archive.html myrosemide, http://alisonmcg.com/ levitra plus 30 pills, http://bunche.org/ accutane, http://www.ewats.info/2011_03_01_archive.html baclofen drug effects side, http://www.ewats.info/p/contact.html avodart cialis clomid diflucan dostinex glucophage, http://www.ewats.info/2010_12_01_archive.html plavix, http://deiupcra.com/retailers cialis online, http://bunche.org/index.php?option=com_frontpage&Itemid=1 antabuse, http://www.ewats.info/ nolvadex,

_ купить плед недорого (2012-02-09 05:17)

c, http://dzelenin.com/pledy.html элитные пледы,

_ вязаные пледы схемы (2012-02-09 06:04)

f, http://dzelenin.com/pledy.html вязание пледы покрывала,

_ массажная подушка купить (2012-02-09 06:05)

a, http://dzelenin.com/ арт дизайн постельное белье иваново,

_ Jkalopadert (2012-02-09 08:48)

http://www.buyonlineclomid.com#63355 buy clomid citrate - purchase clomid

_ Talxciehfkjs (2012-02-09 08:51)

http://www.buycelebrex-cheap.com#271263466 where to buy celebrex cheap - buy celebrex pfizer

_ hzcjrnfs (2012-02-09 15:44)

R0abXD <a href="http://nbyvqtxrdzqr.com/">nbyvqtxrdzqr</a>, [url=http://indaqegnmryy.com/]indaqegnmryy[/url], [link=http://ybmllntmtolt.com/]ybmllntmtolt[/link], http://lzboqfbzrhvn.com/

_ wlvdeyin (2012-02-09 16:31)

8R06tG <a href="http://qadwyyrxdhtv.com/">qadwyyrxdhtv</a>, [url=http://pvmgudtckjkn.com/]pvmgudtckjkn[/url], [link=http://bwndktzteqtz.com/]bwndktzteqtz[/link], http://ydwrotshfpue.com/


日記内検索

最近の更新