Diary


2009-07-21 「汀」の思想。

_ 今福さんの主要文献をひととおり読み終えたいま,本を閉じて瞑目する。そこから立ち上がってくるものは,「汀」の思想とでもいうべきか。

『スポーツの汀』という本を初めて読んだときからずっと引きずっているキー・ワードが「汀」であった。これを「なぎさ」と読むか,「みぎわ」と読むかはその人のことばに対する感性の問題だ。わたし自身はまぎらわしいので,普通には「なぎさ」と言い表し,「なぎさ」として語ることにしている。しかし,ひとりで思考を深めようとするときには「みぎわ」と読む。この方が,思考が深まるように思うから。それは単なる感覚の問題だ。これといった根拠はない。

いずれも,土と水の間(あわい),陸地と海水のせめぎ合うところ,空中と水中の境界領域。海岸をイメージすれば,波が打ち寄せると海中となり,波が引いていくと陸地となる,そんなことを繰り返している,なんとも断定のしようのない混沌の領域。固定を嫌って変化しつづける,そういうカオスでありつづける領域。仏教でいえば「無常」。「つねでない」「変化しつづける」ことこそが「実相」であり,そこには「実体」はない,と仏教は教える。『般若心経』の世界は,まさに,その理(ことわり)を説いたものだ。だから,「是諸法空相」と説く。

では,ほんとうになにもないのか,というとそうではない。「みぎわ」には,あるときは「水」があり,あるときは「土」がある。そのいずれもが「みぎわ」なのである。それが「実相」なのである。その両者が「接触」しながら,お互いになにかを「分割/分有」していくこと,まさに,流動的に変化しつづけること,それが「実相」であり,「みぎわ」の姿なのだ。だからこそ,この「みぎわ」に絶大なる「信」をおくしかない。すべては,ここから「はじまる」からだ。

小さな小川の「みぎわ」を想定してみようか。草が生い茂っていたり,砂地であったり,あるいは,大きな岩であったりする。それぞれのところで流れる水は,それぞれの他者と遭遇することになる。それでも,それぞれに「接触」し,なにかを「分割/分有」しながら,流れつづける。「三尺流れて水清む」とむかしから俚諺が教えている。汚れた水も「三尺」流れると,浄化されてきれいな水になる,という教えである。この「三尺」の間になにが起こっているのか。自然のままの川は偉大な浄化装置でもあったのだ。しかし,近代になると,川幅を「固定」するために「コンクリート」で護岸した。とたんに,「どぶ川」の誕生となった。川のもつ「浄化装置」を失ってしまったのだ。「みぎわ」がなくなってしまったからだ。

これが「<今福龍太>論・私的読解」のひとつのサンプル。

では,今福さんは,なにゆえに「汀」をキー・タームとして,「批評」の拠点としたのか。ここが問題だ。

文化人類学者として,若くして,ブラジルとメキシコとカリブ海をフィールドにして,しかも「ディスクライブ」ではなくて「インスクライブ」の方法をとろうとした。それは,距離をおいた「観察」や,ちょっとだけ触れる「参与観察」でもなく,みずからの肌をとおして「じかに」異文化と「接触」することだった。ここから今福さんはなにを「透視」したのか。文化人類学が対象とするフィールドのほとんどの異文化が,ヨーロッパ近代の植民地支配をとおして,ずたずたに引き裂かれ,みるも無残な姿に変化・変容を余儀なくされてきたか,という一方的な「暴力」であった。ここでは詳しくは述べないが,いわゆる文化の「クレオール化」現象が起こったのである。その典型がカリブ海で起こった。人間の混血はもとより,言語の混淆と絶滅とまったく新しい拳固の誕生,などなど。そして,やがてこの「クレオール化」現象を通過することによって,新しく誕生した「クレオール文化」を生きるしか方法のない人びとが,みずからのアイデンティティを確認する営みをはじめる。そのとき,このような事態を引き起こした「ヨーロッパ」とはいったいなにであったのか,という自覚をもってクレオール語を駆使した新たな「文学」が誕生する。

クレオールとは,まさに,土着とヨーロッパとの「みぎわ」から生まれた,まったく新しい文化なのである。クレオール文化にあっては,すでに,土着もヨーロッパも存在しない。あるのは,土着的なるものとヨーロッパ的なるものとの「折り合い」のつけ方だけである。そこに立ち現れる景観は,まさに,「汀」そのものでしかない。ヨーロッパ的なる波が打ち寄せてくると土着的なるものは覆い隠されるが,すぐに,その波は引いていき,つぎは土着的なるものがその場を独占する。こうして,絶えず,交互に主張し,譲り合いしながら一定の調和を保ちながら,変化・変容を重ねていく。

クレオール主義とは,ここを原点にして,まったく新しい文化の可能性を探っていこうではないか,また,ここにしか人類の未来は展望しえないのではないかという思想運動なのである。この思想は,今福さんの『クレオール主義』のなかにもちらりと顔をみせる「脱構築」(デリダ)の思想とも通底している。言ってしまえば,徹底したヨーロッパ近代に対する批判であり,批評の根拠をなすものである。

これが時を経て,『群島─世界論』になり(ここでもやはり,群島と大陸との「汀」を軸にした世界論が展開されている),『ミニマ・グラシア』(最小限の恩寵とは,もはや失うものはなにもない,そういう状態でもなおかつ最後の「生きる」喜びのひとかけらだけは保証しようではないか,という主張とわたしは理解している)を生み,そういうことと深く連動し,共振・共鳴する批評として『ブラジルのホモ・ルーデンス』がある,というのが現段階でのわたしの読解である。

「汀」の思想こそ,今福さんの「クレオール主義」の原点にあるものであって,この思想なしには,サッカー批評原論も生まれなかったことを肝に銘すべしであろう。ましてや,「フェイント」などであろうはずがない。わたしの意とするところおわかりいただけたであろうか。

本日のツッコミ(全100件) [ツッコミを入れる]
_ 925 (2009-07-24 11:31)

「汀」について以下の文章に刺激を受けた・・・「みぎわ」には,あるときは「水」があり,あるときは「土」がある。そのいずれもが「みぎわ」なのである。それが「実相」なのである。その両者が「接触」しながら,お互いになにかを「分割/分有」していくこと,まさに,流動的に変化しつづけること,それが「実相」であり,「みぎわ」の姿なのだ。だからこそ,この「みぎわ」に絶大なる「信」をおくしかない。すべては,ここから「はじまる」からだ・・・この文章にしばし宙を見つめ、色々と考える機会をいただいた。あるときは「水」あるときは「土」、その反復は繰り返されるが、しかしその汀の境界は2度と同じ形で「水/土」を分割分有しない。「汀」が「差異ある反復」を見事に一言であらわした語であることを改めて気づいた。それに「信」をおくという語に刺激をうけた。<br> クレオールを考えるときに「汀」の思考でないと語れないことが実感できた。このような文化の流動を「アイデンティティ」(以前わたしは無意識にこの語を使っていたが・・・)をいう語に引きずられて説明してしまうと、近代論理から抜け出せないなかで自閉してしまうような気がする。アイデンティティと汀の語の差異が少し見えたような感じがした。

_ yuqfcjglzg (2011-11-07 06:22)

yOhlPT <a href="http://yfgximwbdhec.com/">yfgximwbdhec</a>, [url=http://ldfwjzxmoiww.com/]ldfwjzxmoiww[/url], [link=http://qscltaxwefmg.com/]qscltaxwefmg[/link], http://etycjyfaxikz.com/

_ Czahrggdf (2012-01-06 02:35)

http://www.buynolvadexsite.com#39300 buy cheap nolvadex australia - order nolvadex canada

_ Czahrggdf (2012-01-06 02:35)

http://www.buynolvadexsite.com#39300 buy nolvadex no prescription - buy generic nolvadex online

_ Czahrggdf (2012-01-06 02:49)

http://www.buynolvadexsite.com#39300 buy nolvadex online no prescription - nolvadex tamoxifen citrate for sale

_ Czahrggdf (2012-01-06 02:49)

http://www.buynolvadexsite.com#39300 buy nolvadex with no prescription - buy nolvadex mexico

_ Czahrggdf (2012-01-06 02:50)

http://www.buynolvadexsite.com#39300 buy nolvadex online india - buy nolvadex tablets

_ Czahefgui (2012-01-06 17:43)

http://www.buypriligynow.com#82260 priligy 60 mg - buy priligy no prescription

_ Czahefgui (2012-01-06 17:57)

http://www.buypriligynow.com#82260 priligy dapoxetine buy - priligy 60 mg tablets

_ Czahefgui (2012-01-06 17:58)

http://www.buypriligynow.com#82260 priligy canada pharmacy - priligy dapoxetine australia

_ Czahefgui (2012-01-06 17:59)

http://www.buypriligynow.com#82260 order priligy dapoxetine - buy priligy no prescription

_ Fillippo (2012-01-07 13:27)

memussabob, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21656 Cod Online TRAMADOL, ydb, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21730 Ultram Xenical Hgh-saizen Nexium, 618, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21715 TRAMADOL 400 Pills, 56544, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21662 TRAMADOL Online Ordering, 916533, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21713 Taking TRAMADOL While Breast Feeding, 39598, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21733 Buy TRAMADOL Ups Delivered, fdlmpl, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21657 Loratab TRAMADOL, >:-PP, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21722 Celexa And TRAMADOL, >:DDD, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21721 Fentanyl Interaction With Ultram, 90353, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21714 Onlinenmru Ultram, opns,

_ Siuzan (2012-01-07 14:12)

bolinoke, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21661 White And Round TRAMADOL, :DDD, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21730 TRAMADOL Recreational, :)), https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21724 Cheap Generic Ultram, wkktv, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21722 TRAMADOL In Mexican Pharmacies, =)), https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21724 TRAMADOL As Diet Drug, >:-PPP, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21721 Ultram Controlled Substance Classification, 8012, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21730 Taking Ultram, zfnyjl, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21732 Best TRAMADOL Online, 8P, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21713 Take TRAMADOL While Pregnant, =-[[[, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21725 Ultram 100 Mg, 748958,

_ Gidravzo (2012-01-07 14:57)

dwarasit,

_ Fillippo (2012-01-07 15:44)

wersdesda, http://nitix.grou.ps/talks/6779029 TRAMADOL Dogs Dosage Information, euh, http://breasts.grou.ps/talks/6778987 Prescribed TRAMADOL For, 6962, http://fatalascension.grou.ps/talks/6779080 TRAMADOL Show Up On Drug Test, 8-), http://1as1.grou.ps/talks/6778964 Buy TRAMADOL Hydrochloride, 8DD, http://fatalascension.grou.ps/talks/6779077 Fioricet Butalbital Phentermine Ultram Tramdol, 294, http://rmmforums.grou.ps/talks/6779105 Information On Medicine TRAMADOL, >:(, http://livefucking.grou.ps/talks/6778999 Line Ultram, sco, http://area-de-projecto.grou.ps/talks/6779007 Cost TRAMADOL, >:[[[, http://livefucking.grou.ps/talks/6778998 Peoples Comments On TRAMADOL, >:(((, http://rmmforums.grou.ps/talks/6779102 Is TRAMADOL And Avinza Together Bad, 65977,

_ Siuzan (2012-01-07 16:29)

voipyxou, http://rmmforums.grou.ps/talks/6779107 Ultram Blow Dryer, vmenmz, http://nitix.grou.ps/talks/6779027 TRAMADOL Cheap TRAMADOL, 830, http://livefucking.grou.ps/talks/6778998 Is A Prescription Required For TRAMADOL, 5654, http://fatalascension.grou.ps/talks/6779074 Ultram Day, fsz, http://atm88lib.grou.ps/talks/6778955 TRAMADOL An 267, 248, http://livefucking.grou.ps/talks/6779000 TRAMADOL After Morphine Drip, fbdm, http://adivinator.grou.ps/talks/6779015 Is Ultram Addicting, >:O, http://rmmforums.grou.ps/talks/6779105 Information On Prescribe Drug Ultram, 612059, http://1as1.grou.ps/talks/6778965 Uses For TRAMADOL, 167207, http://area-de-projecto.grou.ps/talks/6779007 Ultram Withdrawal Ultram, 553218,

_ Markello (2012-01-07 17:15)

lideraro,

_ Markello (2012-01-07 18:01)

ucbudis, http://nitix.grou.ps/talks/6779033 Order TRAMADOLs, 860, http://breasts.grou.ps/talks/6778984 TRAMADOL Hydrochloride Capsules, zqt, http://nitix.grou.ps/talks/6779031 Vicodin TRAMADOL Interactions, =[[[, http://1as1.grou.ps/talks/6778969 Drugs Forum TRAMADOL With Soma, max, http://livefucking.grou.ps/talks/6779000 Pharmacy Degree Buy TRAMADOL, :OOO, http://rmmforums.grou.ps/talks/6779116 Problems With TRAMADOL, 66338, http://livefucking.grou.ps/talks/6778995 TRAMADOL And Sex Drive, qnxtug, http://fatalascension.grou.ps/talks/6779088 Flexeril Vs TRAMADOL, 8-[[[, http://adivinator.grou.ps/talks/6779024 TRAMADOL And Long Term, 90657, http://livefucking.grou.ps/talks/6778995 Is TRAMADOL More Potent Than Hydrocodone, tnzwro,

_ Siuzan (2012-01-07 18:48)

counttaga,

_ Gidravzo (2012-01-07 19:33)

dalasal,

_ Markello (2012-01-07 20:19)

staricocar,

_ Markello (2012-01-07 21:05)

riepresta,

_ Anverto (2012-01-07 21:51)

tenvemen,

_ Marchello (2012-01-07 22:38)

ualnancurr,

_ Marchello (2012-01-07 23:25)

sectogeret,

_ Markello (2012-01-08 00:13)

buistopin,

_ Siuzan (2012-01-08 01:02)

burtiotu,

_ Siuzan (2012-01-08 01:51)

neufillmep, http://ouscss.com/drupal/node/173136 TRAMADOL Buy On Line, =))), http://ouscss.com/drupal/node/173149 Drug Screen Ultram, :OO, http://ouscss.com/drupal/node/173095 TRAMADOL No Prescription Overnight Delivery, >:-)), http://ouscss.com/drupal/node/173057 Can Egg Donation And TRAMADOL, 710, http://ouscss.com/drupal/node/173057 Dogs TRAMADOL Artritus, 711, http://ouscss.com/drupal/node/173085 TRAMADOL And Alcohol Side Effects, hszfg, http://ouscss.com/drupal/node/173126 Buy Cheap TRAMADOL TRAMADOL Ultram, 238, http://ouscss.com/drupal/node/173093 Ultram Tmj, 846593, http://ouscss.com/drupal/node/173082 TRAMADOL And Opioid Hyperalgesia, 880281, http://ouscss.com/drupal/node/173138 Buy TRAMADOL Site, vypxix,

_ Fillippo (2012-01-08 02:39)

icovtic,

_ Markello (2012-01-08 03:26)

wesreliten, http://ysyouthprayersforjapan.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6987022-tramadol-drug-test TRAMADOL And Long Term Effects, :-DD, http://nocontestband.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6983518-online-pharmacy-tramadol TRAMADOL 180 Fedex, =OO, http://riversoflivingwatercf.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6986831-tramadol-medicines Time Fram Of Ultram Withdrawal, sqi, http://nocontestband.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6983526-lowest-prices-tramadol Ultram TRAMADOL Abuse, 986414, http://hottramp.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6983367-buy-cod-tramadol 7 TRAMADOL, 934,

_ Siuzan (2012-01-08 04:13)

dalasal,

_ Anverto (2012-01-08 05:00)

faecatcu,

_ Gidravzo (2012-01-08 05:46)

berramorusp,

_ Marchello (2012-01-08 06:33)

litisjetsmo, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15162 TRAMADOL What Class Of Drug, %-(((, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15165 TRAMADOL Recall, 8-(, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15167 TRAMADOL Saturday Cod Delivery, vtxkga, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15161 Acyclovir Aldara TRAMADOL, =D, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15167 Order Cheapest TRAMADOL, qtfcif,

_ Marchello (2012-01-08 07:18)

vaomocobbgran, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15163 Ultram Warning Blood Test, :P, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15162 Information About TRAMADOL, 8-D, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15161 Ultram Overnight Cod, =-DD, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15158 Possible TRAMADOL Drug Interactions, >:(, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15164 Cheapest TRAMADOL Next Day Delivery, 9202,

_ Marchello (2012-01-08 08:01)

rekosiga, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15159 TRAMADOL On Line No Prescription, 8-DDD, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15163 TRAMADOL Lactation, ifku, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15165 Use Of TRAMADOL In Fibromyalgia, tytsyq, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15158 TRAMADOL Uk, 579423, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15159 Ultram Class Of Medication, lzma,

_ Siuzan (2012-01-08 08:44)

kaspipo, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15161 Pharmacy Tech Buy TRAMADOL, 9376, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15163 Get TRAMADOL Hydrochloride Working, 9223, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15165 Aggrenox TRAMADOL Finasteride, 750, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15160 Ultram Cheap Online, 8-(((, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15163 Is TRAMADOL A Safe Pain Reliever, >:-[[[,

_ Marchello (2012-01-08 09:28)

viacoxdi, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15160 Is Ultram Like Vicodin, 29392, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15165 Generic Ultram Generic, 402377, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15158 TRAMADOL Veterinary Dosage Chart, 0238, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15160 TRAMADOL And Wellbutrin, 96542, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15163 Long Term Effects And Ultram, 082636,

_ Siuzan (2012-01-08 10:12)

taremou,

_ Marchello (2012-01-08 10:57)

taweri, http://smule.com/forums/16/topics/15599 Extracting TRAMADOL, kvy, http://smule.com/forums/16/topics/15615 TRAMADOL And Methadone, xaba, http://smule.com/forums/16/topics/15601 Ultram Er, aitc, http://smule.com/forums/16/topics/15604 Ultram Medicein, 591, http://smule.com/forums/16/topics/15599 TRAMADOL Or Ultram Is Prescribed For, 730101, http://smule.com/forums/16/topics/15612 TRAMADOL Next Day Air, ync, http://smule.com/forums/16/topics/15602 How Does TRAMADOL Look, %DDD, http://smule.com/forums/16/topics/15613 TRAMADOL An 627, 13753, http://smule.com/forums/16/topics/15620 Contraindication Of TRAMADOL And Elavil, ffx, http://smule.com/forums/16/topics/15604 Ultram Er 100mg, 8)),

_ Marchello (2012-01-08 11:43)

stimnate,

_ Markello (2012-01-08 12:29)

racuthel,

_ Markello (2012-01-08 13:14)

acwaycassa,

_ Fillippo (2012-01-08 14:01)

flashydci, http://tristategunandarchery.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/7011050-soma-milligrams Bruce A SOMA, 81994, http://forumfans.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/7011705-soma-online-free-overnight-shipping SOMA Online, 19032, http://tristategunandarchery.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/7011054-buy-cod-online-soma Effects SOMA Erowid, 6135, http://tristategunandarchery.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/7011379-normal-dose-of-soma Uk Carisoprodol, =)), http://tristategunandarchery.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/7011133-buy-soma-online-prescription Drugs Carisoprodol, apza, http://tristategunandarchery.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/7011082-soma-online-free-shipping SOMA Hotel, %]], http://tristategunandarchery.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/7011343-soma-free-ship-coupon Diet Phentermine Carisoprodol, lktxq, http://tristategunandarchery.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/7011239-buy-soma-online SOMA Beds, gusmm, http://tristategunandarchery.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/7011239-buy-soma-online Next Day Carisoprodol, wwk, http://tristategunandarchery.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/7011087-soma-sleep-apnea-pillow SOMA Sleep Apnea Pillow, >:-P,

_ Markello (2012-01-08 14:49)

tihybmo,

_ Anverto (2012-01-08 15:37)

holpohosqui, http://forumfans.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/7011645-cheap-cod-online-soma Club SOMA San Diego, jhe, http://tristategunandarchery.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/7011239-buy-soma-online Cory Haim SOMA, vpqo, http://forumfans.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/7011478-information-on-drug-soma What Company Produces SOMA Muscle Relaxant, elhnk, http://forumfans.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/7011487-soma-carisoprodol-online Carisoprodol Coupon, %-(((, http://forumfans.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/7011478-information-on-drug-soma The Rows At SOMA, 8((, http://tristategunandarchery.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/7011130-somas-overnight-with-no-prescription Cruises Carisoprodol, 464, http://tristategunandarchery.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/7011064-buy-in-soma-usa SOMA Online Pharmacies, 6976, http://forumfans.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/7011705-soma-online-free-overnight-shipping Carisoprodol Link Onlinefrontru, 8O, http://tristategunandarchery.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/7011239-buy-soma-online SOMA And Breast-feeding, >:], http://tristategunandarchery.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/7011239-buy-soma-online SOMA Ship Texas, %OOO,

_ Siuzan (2012-01-08 16:25)

spamrasym,

_ Siuzan (2012-01-08 17:13)

miophidenslocc, http://forumfans.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/7011645-cheap-cod-online-soma Anime Couple Torhu And SOMA, bdoz, http://forumfans.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/7011487-soma-carisoprodol-online Fda SOMA 250 Mg, pmzqv, http://tristategunandarchery.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/7011360-next-day-meds-soma Carisoprodol Spiritual, iatek, http://tristategunandarchery.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/7011050-soma-milligrams SOMA Comma, 306171, http://tristategunandarchery.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/7011377-soma-tea-canada SOMA Wimax Pricing, 9966, http://tristategunandarchery.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/7011050-soma-milligrams Buy SOMAs Online, 099690, http://forumfans.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/7011705-soma-online-free-overnight-shipping Dr SOMA Wali Md, :-), http://tristategunandarchery.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/7011064-buy-in-soma-usa No Prescription Need SOMA Cod, 723187, http://tristategunandarchery.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/7011087-soma-sleep-apnea-pillow Salsa La Ruz Vs SOMA Smoothie, 8]], http://tristategunandarchery.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/7011114-cheapest-soma-online Testimonials Carisoprodol, 8[,

_ Markello (2012-01-08 18:04)

tracdingtema,

_ Markello (2012-01-08 18:56)

nerdegendown,

_ Anverto (2012-01-08 19:46)

leitaviro, http://riversoflivingwatercf.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6986896-tramadol-for-canince Next Day Shipping TRAMADOL, =-(, http://lookintokannasmirror.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6986357-buy-tramadol-online-cheap 1 Order Ultram, >:OO, http://forumfans.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6983199-tramadol-side-effects Symptoms Of TRAMADOL Withdrawal, hqh, http://gspd.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6984304-cod-tramadol-saturday 00 79 Cheap TRAMADOL, =-PPP, http://nocontestband.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6983510-tramadol-online Can You Take TRAMADOL Mobic Together, >:-D,

_ Marchello (2012-01-08 20:35)

lunriehy,

_ Marchello (2012-01-08 21:23)

orsona,

_ Anverto (2012-01-08 22:15)

aneras, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924608 Dps Ultram, 8DDD, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924704 TRAMADOL M Print On One Side, fnsrh, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924646 Is Ultram Stronger Than Vicodin, 599498, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924646 TRAMADOL Clorhidrato Genfar, %-))), http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924646 Cheap TRAMADOL Ssales, >:-[,

_ Gidravzo (2012-01-08 23:08)

guifretcomlo, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924768 Does TRAMADOL Cause Hair Loss, kesa, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924690 Cheap Order Prescription TRAMADOL, =-P, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924714 Vicodin Or Ultram, 086796, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924464 Uses Of Ultram Or TRAMADOL, sufvn, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924690 How To Quit Ultram, 982,

_ Fillippo (2012-01-09 00:02)

seylitmapa, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924608 TRAMADOL Zoloft Siezure, zadwu, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924768 TRAMADOL Walgreens, wwweok, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924646 TRAMADOL Ecstasy Online, 689, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924646 Online Pharmacy TRAMADOL Usps, 853607, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924630 Ultram And The Liver, durfm,

_ Gidravzo (2012-01-09 00:56)

dibdoreappdo, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924860 Mixing Oxycodone With TRAMADOL, rdh, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924768 Loss Ultram Weight, 317093, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924690 TRAMADOL Withdrawals, yofteh, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924768 TRAMADOL Darvocet Weight Gain, pyfbt, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924714 TRAMADOL Efficasy, 94037,

_ Gidravzo (2012-01-09 01:50)

tratsawi, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924690 Online TRAMADOL, nbkqf, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924464 Paypal No Prescription TRAMADOL, nhl, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924728 TRAMADOL Overnight Delivery Online Prescription, 97246, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924608 Darvon N And TRAMADOL, %-((, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924608 Which Is Stronger TRAMADOL Or Percoset, mhwcmx,

_ Marchello (2012-01-09 02:41)

anexcasurf, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924728 TRAMADOL Online Overnight No Prescription, pyzr, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924646 TRAMADOL Blood Thinner, 061336, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924608 TRAMADOL Xr, 9307, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924714 TRAMADOL Saturday Delivery No Prescription, 0786, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924728 All About TRAMADOL Provision, mjg,

_ Fillippo (2012-01-09 03:31)

inabber, http://medferma.webs.com/thetramadolcatalog.htm TRAMADOL Er Dosages, qrxoi, http://medferma.webs.com/bestpricefortramadol.htm Ultram After First Trimester, 05768, http://medferma.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6954934-buy-tramadol-best-prices- TRAMADOL Tremor Side Effect, 09012, http://medferma.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6954934-buy-tramadol-best-prices- All Uses For Ultram, fwjwac, http://medferma.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6954922-buy-tramdol-great-prices TRAMADOL Doesnt Work, eds,

_ Anverto (2012-01-09 04:21)

gransewhea, http://medferma.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6954918-tramadol-order-online- TRAMADOL Pain Medication, znqzso, http://medferma.webs.com/buyonlinehere.htm Ultram Dependence Treatment, 65687, http://medferma.webs.com/thetramadolcatalog.htm Is Ultram Stronger Than Vicoden, ypix, http://medferma.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6954925-tramadol-brand-and-generic-great-quality- Dogs TRAMADOL Arthritis, qtjy, http://medferma.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6954934-buy-tramadol-best-prices- Can Inject Ultram, 506,

_ Gidravzo (2012-01-09 05:12)

inmasunwealth, http://medferma.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6954934-buy-tramadol-best-prices- TRAMADOL Sale, 3454, http://medferma.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6954925-tramadol-brand-and-generic-great-quality- Will TRAMADOL Cause Liver Problems, 0708, http://medferma.webs.com/tramadolonline.htm Ultram For Fibromyalgia, 893225, http://medferma.webs.com/bestpricefortramadol.htm Low Price Ultram, >:[[, http://medferma.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6954930-buy-tramadol-brand-and-generic- Ultram Cheap Online, :O,

_ Czahrgkoih (2012-01-09 05:12)

http://www.buy-tramadol-med.com#98408 buy tramadol no rx - buy cheap tramadol no prescription online

_ Czahrgkoih (2012-01-09 05:12)

http://www.buy-tramadol-med.com#98408 tramadol no prescription free shipping - tramadol no prescription

_ Czahrgkoih (2012-01-09 05:27)

http://www.buy-tramadol-med.com#98408 buy tramadol usa - buy tramadol online overnight

_ Czahrgkoih (2012-01-09 05:27)

http://www.buy-tramadol-med.com#98408 tramadol online reviews - buy cheap tramadol online no prescription

_ Czahrgkoih (2012-01-09 05:28)

http://www.buy-tramadol-med.com#98408 buy tramadol online no prescription overnight - buy tramadol no prescription overnight

_ Czahrgkoih (2012-01-09 05:32)

http://www.buy-tramadol-med.com#98408 buy tramadol rx - cheap tramadol no prescription overnight

_ Gidravzo (2012-01-09 05:59)

ciecedafli,

_ Fillippo (2012-01-09 06:48)

terasvitas,

_ Marchello (2012-01-09 07:36)

abpata, http://amizkos.tumblr.com/post/13552589648/casino-free-play-cupon no deposit required online casino, %]], http://amizkos.tumblr.com no deposit casino deposit, 1895, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21273 game internet online, qwh, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21273 free casino game downloads, 249, http://amizkos.tumblr.com/post/13552589648/casino-free-play-cupon casino cyber gambling online, 904825,

_ Anverto (2012-01-09 08:24)

windfacbee, http://amizkos.tumblr.com no deposit free chip casino, 71174, http://amizkos.tumblr.com free web casino games, :-]]], http://amizkos.tumblr.com free casino affiliate website, 707114, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21274 online casino bonuse, =(, http://amizkos.tumblr.com/post/13552411001/las-vegas-casino-online-game best casino jobs, =-OOO,

_ Marchello (2012-01-09 09:10)

beschtucal, http://amizkos.tumblr.com/post/13550656485/classic-casino-no-deposit best online casino sportsbook, 0750, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21276 casinos no download signup free money, 8((, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21275 watch casino royale 2006 divx online, ecj, http://amizkos.tumblr.com/post/13552411001/las-vegas-casino-online-game free spin online casino, ypqmkl, http://amizkos.tumblr.com/post/13550617542/casino-free-slot free king solomons casino, 014,

_ Gidravzo (2012-01-09 09:57)

blowupun,

_ Marchello (2012-01-09 10:44)

ovunprat, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21274 money no deposit casino free bonus, 70938, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21252 hingo black casino jack poker free, ayob, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21275 freemont street casinos vegas, :-OOO, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21276 best casino casino dummy, zdspl, http://amizkos.tumblr.com free casino game win prize, 8P,

_ Fillippo (2012-01-09 11:33)

membbopi, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035630 TRAMADOL Cheap 120 Pills, 523013, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035654 TRAMADOL For Long Term, xxuhju, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035706 Increase Effects Of TRAMADOL, utnjt, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035604 TRAMADOL Overdose, 60564, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035592 Ultram 50mg Used For, 33818, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035390 Ultram London Pharmacies, 8-[, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035628 TRAMADOL 50 Mg Fro Canine, vyhy, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035554 Best Dosage TRAMADOL, 907929, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035672 Buy TRAMADOL Online, nlesfl, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035634 Order TRAMADOL Saturday Delivery, 761514,

_ Markello (2012-01-09 12:21)

dispnevilmye, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035686 TRAMADOL Ingredients, 6438, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035390 TRAMADOL Pharmacy Tech Career Cheap TRAMADOL, 219454, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035642 TRAMADOL Abuse With Lomotil, fnilq, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035626 Combine Ultram Er 200 Subutex, fhuso, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035492 TRAMADOL Feline, =((, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035492 Ultram For Headache, kqogr, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035484 Safe To Mix Methadone And TRAMADOL, :), http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035580 Celebrex And Ultram, iszmzn, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035626 Is TRAMADOL A Synthetic Opiate Image, bel, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035402 Buy TRAMADOL Tablets, jcr,

_ Anverto (2012-01-09 13:08)

neykatlores, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035636 TRAMADOL Coagulation, pqhcrf, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035634 TRAMADOL Extened Release, %-))), http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035654 Getting High On TRAMADOL, 8-], http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035542 Medication And TRAMADOL Hcl And Information, =-DD, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035674 TRAMADOL Penalty Group, >:-OO, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035580 Which Country TRAMADOL Without Prescription, dbbq, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035502 Cheap No Prescription TRAMADOL, >:-))), http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035608 TRAMADOL Drug Insert, 8DD, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035650 Oxycodone TRAMADOL, xyudg, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035654 TRAMADOL Dog Dosage, 8-O,

_ Anverto (2012-01-09 13:54)

sissiopopon, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035542 TRAMADOL Fo9r Back Pain, 3968, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035702 Ultram Er 100mg, 763, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035644 TRAMADOL Before Online, >:-O, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035680 Domain Onlinenmru Ultram, 8DDD, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035674 Will TRAMADOL Help Backpain And Headaches, :)), http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035390 Lowest Priced TRAMADOL, 8O, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035634 Are TRAMADOL Addictive, 896, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035630 Arthritis Antibiotic With Ultram, >:-[[[, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035484 High TRAMADOL, 47393, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035468 TRAMADOL Abuse Sniff, 2122,

_ Fillippo (2012-01-09 14:42)

britarfefi,

_ Gidravzo (2012-01-09 15:30)

fledtadoscy, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21657 What Kind Of Medication Is Ultram, qlh, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21657 Ultram Prescribed For Dogs And People, %]]], https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21656 Cod Pay Ultram, 80118, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21717 TRAMADOL $0.29 Per Pill, gtgra, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21714 What Schedule Drug Is Ultram, >:[[[, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21733 Buy Cheap TRAMADOL O, 8), https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21729 Buy TRAMADOL Online Pharmacy Saturday Delivery, =-]], https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21717 Ultram Compared To Vioxx, 8P, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21715 Buy Fast Online Ultram, bofgca, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21658 Ultram Ex, 653,

_ Siuzan (2012-01-09 16:17)

raitraviner, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21655 Alcohol Ultram, %-(((, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21729 Fedex Overnight Free Shipping TRAMADOL, >:(((, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21730 TRAMADOL Ibs, %[[, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21720 Site About TRAMADOL Punishment, kxzgc, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21733 Ultram Withdrawla, %-DD, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21735 TRAMADOL Good For Depression, 8O, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21658 TRAMADOL Withdraw, zcfrg, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21659 Addiction Story Ultram, xenp, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21725 TRAMADOL Prints, 20612, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21732 TRAMADOL Treatment For Depression, %-P,

_ Siuzan (2012-01-09 17:04)

cigangmu,

_ Markello (2012-01-09 17:53)

klarergauva,

_ Fillippo (2012-01-09 18:40)

fedpaman,

_ Gidravzo (2012-01-09 19:27)

requacfiwar, http://nitix.grou.ps/talks/6779031 Ultram Pdr, =-[[, http://nitix.grou.ps/talks/6779027 TRAMADOL For Dog Usage Information, 40528, http://atm88lib.grou.ps/talks/6778960 TRAMADOL Dentist, 405, http://nitix.grou.ps/talks/6779026 TRAMADOL White And Round, 402621, http://fatalascension.grou.ps/talks/6779086 Drug Interaction TRAMADOL, =))), http://nitix.grou.ps/talks/6779030 Ultram Buy Online, ietkp, http://1as1.grou.ps/talks/6778971 Ultram After First Trimester, 340, http://rmmforums.grou.ps/talks/6779107 50mg TRAMADOL, 959150, http://fatalascension.grou.ps/talks/6779073 Ultram Cheapest, 724959, http://breasts.grou.ps/talks/6778981 TRAMADOL Journals Quizilla, 1492,

_ Siuzan (2012-01-09 20:15)

stufesic,

_ Markello (2012-01-09 21:03)

daseamensui,

_ Marchello (2012-01-09 21:51)

skogwartigold,

_ Fillippo (2012-01-09 22:39)

projuntaco,

_ Fillippo (2012-01-09 23:27)

crazlagurre, http://labs.divx.com/node/53390 TRAMADOL Janssen, 05048, http://labs.divx.com/node/53390 TRAMADOL Dosage, >:[, http://labs.divx.com/node/53390 Soma Taken With TRAMADOL Experiences, %PPP, http://labs.divx.com/node/53388 Ultram Pharmacy Line, sxfgmn, http://labs.divx.com/node/53384 Info On TRAMADOL Bending, 97791, http://labs.divx.com/node/53387 Ralivia TRAMADOL Hydrochloride, 8]], http://labs.divx.com/node/53394 Buy Navn TRAMADOL Weblog, =P, http://labs.divx.com/node/53384 Ultram Tylenol 3 Drug Reactions, 594774, http://labs.divx.com/node/53392 TRAMADOL 50mg Tablets, %-PP, http://labs.divx.com/node/53385 Phase Safety Study TRAMADOL Extended, vbcuv,

_ Markello (2012-01-10 00:16)

naldcontcong,

_ Gidravzo (2012-01-10 01:09)

outlaverru, http://labs.divx.com/node/53394 TRAMADOL Treatment For Depression, flea, http://labs.divx.com/node/53380 Generic For Ultram Er, 208, http://labs.divx.com/node/53380 TRAMADOL Use With Cialis, 280518, http://labs.divx.com/node/53394 Pharmacy Online TRAMADOL, oes, http://labs.divx.com/node/53385 Prescription TRAMADOL Buy Cheap, wptwi, http://labs.divx.com/node/53384 TRAMADOL Pill Formats, 8-PPP, http://labs.divx.com/node/53392 Opiate Ultram, bmvnk, http://labs.divx.com/node/53387 Ultram Suboxone, 8220, http://labs.divx.com/node/53393 Cheap TRAMADOL Free Shipping, eyvh, http://labs.divx.com/node/53388 50 Mg Ultram, 8568,

_ Czahrgijko (2012-01-10 01:13)

http://www.buyimitrexpharmacy.com#31570 buy generic imitrex online - buy imitrex tablets online

_ Czahrgijko (2012-01-10 01:30)

http://www.buyimitrexpharmacy.com#31570 buy sumatriptan succinate - cheap imitrex no prescription

_ Czahrgijko (2012-01-10 01:31)

http://www.buyimitrexpharmacy.com#31570 buy imitrex no prescription - generic imitrex online

_ Czahrgijko (2012-01-10 01:31)

http://www.buyimitrexpharmacy.com#31570 buy sumatriptan europe - generic imitrex uk

_ Czahrgijko (2012-01-10 01:34)

http://www.buyimitrexpharmacy.com#31570 generic of imitrex - buy imitrex usa

_ Gidravzo (2012-01-10 01:59)

clicsichtcrit, http://labs.divx.com/node/53387 What Do You Take TRAMADOL For, udpo, http://labs.divx.com/node/53387 TRAMADOL Dosing Calculations, moegpl, http://labs.divx.com/node/53388 TRAMADOL And Lymph Nodes, 8DD, http://labs.divx.com/node/53393 Ultram And Giddiness, :-P, http://labs.divx.com/node/53393 Des Valium Help TRAMADOL Wean, 15189, http://labs.divx.com/node/53384 TRAMADOL A Controlled Substance, 010647, http://labs.divx.com/node/53380 TRAMADOL And Opioid Hyperalgesia, sehj, http://labs.divx.com/node/53385 50mg Buy Ultram, 132, http://labs.divx.com/node/53375 TRAMADOL And Twiching, %-], http://labs.divx.com/node/53390 Ultram Infomration, %P,

_ Czahrgtuj (2012-01-10 02:28)

http://www.where-to-buy-xanax.com#59830 buy cheap xanax no prescription - buy xanax online reviews


日記内検索

最近の更新