2009-07-24 倫理的な態度，とは？
_ わたしには，いまだに，「倫理」とか「倫理学」というものがピンとこない。なんの計算も打算もない純粋無垢な「倫理」とはなにか。
これまでに『スポーツ倫理学』と名のつく本を３冊ほど読んでみたが，どう考えてみても納得いかない。「医の倫理」ということばも，いまひとつ，ピンとこない。とりわけ，臓器移植にかかわる「医の倫理」となると，ますますわからなくなってしまう。だから，「スポーツの倫理」といわれても，どうもよくわからない。靄がかかったままだ。
今福さんの『ミニマ・グラシア』の帯に「私は，自分にとっておそらくもっとも倫理的な態度のもとに書き継がれたテクストを収めた本書で，自らの意思や欲望の饒舌な氾濫が沈黙とぶつかり合う真空のような領域にまで降りていった。私は重力が真空と触れ合うこの認識の狭い領域で，歴史を反歴史の水際から語ろうとしたのである」と書かれているのをみて，ほんのわずかに「あっ」と思った。そして，久しぶりにこの本をあちこち拾い読みしながら，今福さんのいう「倫理的な態度」というものを探ってみた。そこから，なんとなく透けて見えてきたものがある。
それは「生と死」が触れ合う「コンタクト・ゾーン」（これまでのわたしの用語でいえば「境界領域」，そして，今福さんの用語でいえば「汀」）に立って，人が「生きる」ということの根源に横たわる野性の「力」（force，フォルス)をどのように見きわめ，その「力」との「折り合い」をどのようにつけるか，というときに立ち上がるものが「倫理」ではないか，と。そして，このことに忠実に応答しようとする態度こそが「倫理的な態度」というものではないか，と。誤解を恐れずにいってしまえば，「生死との折り合い」のつけ方ではないか，と。ここの問題を抜きにして「倫理」「倫理的態度」と声高に言われても，いま一つ，わたしにはピンとこないのである。
今福さんが，この『ミニマ・グラシア』をとおしていいたかったことは，「９・１１」以後の「戦争」による無意味な人の「死」にピリオドを打つ方法はないものか，というやむにやまれない「希求」からである。そのためには，あえて，「歴史を反歴史の水際」から語るしかない，と決断して筆をとったというのが真相であろう。だから，「自らの意思や欲望の饒舌な氾濫が沈黙とぶつかり合う真空のような領域にまで降りて」いく必要があったのだ。これこそが，今福さんのいう「倫理的態度」というものであろう。みずから無神論者であるという今福さんのことばでいえば「真空のような領域」ということになるのであろうが，わたしのような禅仏教に信をおいている者からすれば，これは，まぎれもなき「修証一如」の世界である。坐禅をしてかぎりなく自己を「無」にしていったさきで出会う「沈黙」の世界であり，「真空のような領域」である。つまり，いっさいの私利私欲をなげうって，死をも覚悟したさきに広がる世界のことだ。西田幾多郎のことばに直せば，「純粋経験」や「行為的直観」がはたらく「場所」のことだ。そこには，もはや，主体のはたらく余地はない。そういう領域にまで降りていって，なおかつ「重力と真空の触れ合う」（これもまた「汀」である），「この認識の狭い境域」に立ち（これぞ「倫理的態度」だとわたしは思う），「歴史を反歴史の水際」＝「汀」から「語ろうとした」。
ここでいう「歴史」とは，いうまでもなくヨーロッパ近代の論理によって記述された＜歴史＞のことで，それを「反歴史」，つまり，ヨーロッパ近代の論理から排除されてしまった，たんなる「希求」の側から語ってみよう，と今福さんは「倫理的態度」を貫く。こここそが，また，今福さんの「批評精神」のよって立つ基盤でもある。
もう制限時間がきてしまったので，いささか論旨が飛躍するが，「ミニマ・グラシア」，つまり，「最小限の恩寵」とは，「生死」を超越した領域に立ち現れる絶望的な悲哀とないまぜになった「愛」であり，「友情」であり，「エクスタシー」のことである。それは，同時に，「力」（フォルス）の発露でもあるのだ。このつづきは明日の月例会で。
OS4FWH <a href="http://ewfpofhgarhs.com/">ewfpofhgarhs</a>, [url=http://drgomvclfrka.com/]drgomvclfrka[/url], [link=http://fmrbjzsobvys.com/]fmrbjzsobvys[/link], http://taavmimyxjrw.com/
ovpaleso,
thiwinme,
liroter,
mingtroubinpi, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21891 SOMA Bike Frame, ooywgf, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21892 SOMA Safe In Pregnancy, :[[, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21878 SOMA Withdrawal Seizure, nqjh, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21890 SOMA Vison Girls, legoq, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21873 Eating Before SOMA, :(((, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21868 What Is SOMA In The Cns, ndzzx, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21888 SOMA Bringer Original Soundtrack Different Cover, >:-), https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21893 SOMA Without Prescription, gylb, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21885 Minimum Lethal Dosage SOMA, :[[, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21875 Drug SOMA Addictive, tmlglu,
vandbartaiwwhel,
hahostzil, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21885 Watson Carisoprodol, >:), https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21896 SOMA Group Inc, nuylm, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21877 SOMA To Take Effect, xadn, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21886 Carisoprodol Line, ruz, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21892 Lofts At SOMA, 65225, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21873 Dr SOMA Avva, lfzy, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21883 Carisoprodol Gaba, 8(, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21868 SOMA Concerts, 936585, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21876 SOMA Puzzle Math Shapes, 963519, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21896 SOMA Alexandria, 043,
stosamgie,
distnamingtag, http://nitix.grou.ps/talks/6781197 SOMA Youth Camp, keng, http://breasts.grou.ps/talks/6781117 Cp Hydrocodone Carisoprodol, 57034, http://fatalascension.grou.ps/talks/6781222 SOMA Center For Yoga And Meditation, 534, http://fatalascension.grou.ps/talks/6781224 SOMA Studio Denver, zew, http://nitix.grou.ps/talks/6781193 SOMA Christian Living, rovp, http://fatalascension.grou.ps/talks/6781217 SOMA Intimates Website, :[[[, http://fatalascension.grou.ps/talks/6781221 SOMA Galleries, 559, http://nitix.grou.ps/talks/6781204 SOMA Urban Pursuit Bars In Colors, 1075, http://livefucking.grou.ps/talks/6781138 SOMA Medication Driving, :-DD, http://nitix.grou.ps/talks/6781201 350mgfromrucom Carisoprodol, zvlwf,
tmakkasratt, http://nitix.grou.ps/talks/6781196 Overdose Of SOMA, %-((, http://breasts.grou.ps/talks/6781128 SOMA Splint, 40462, http://fatalascension.grou.ps/talks/6781220 Cheapest SOMA Or Carisoprodol Online, jiriyu, http://fatalascension.grou.ps/talks/6781221 Carsioprodol, 99347, http://livefucking.grou.ps/talks/6781139 SOMA Huxley Definition, pyt, http://livefucking.grou.ps/talks/6781145 Usage For Carisoprodol Cpd Wih Codeine, 38052, http://breasts.grou.ps/talks/6781127 Viliam Faber SOMA, qnqtkm, http://nitix.grou.ps/talks/6781205 Buy SOMA Cheap, =-]]], http://rmmforums.grou.ps/talks/6781239 Carisoprodol Pharmacy Online, >:-]], http://area-de-projecto.grou.ps/talks/6781151 Hives On SOMA, iic,
lawntohigh, http://livefucking.grou.ps/talks/6781149 SOMA Residences, mfyts, http://nitix.grou.ps/talks/6781204 Buy Watson Carisoprodol Usa Pharmacy, 26976, http://area-de-projecto.grou.ps/talks/6781152 SOMA 250mg Back Pain, krxk, http://breasts.grou.ps/talks/6781126 SOMA 5, nyoj, http://adivinator.grou.ps/talks/6781172 The SOMA Diet By Sydney Hilton, voua, http://fatalascension.grou.ps/talks/6781220 SOMA Beds, wpb, http://nitix.grou.ps/talks/6781193 Cell SOMA, :-P, http://fatalascension.grou.ps/talks/6781222 SOMA Energetic Vibrational Tuning, wveuxl, http://rmmforums.grou.ps/talks/6781269 SOMA Online Prescriptions, 503653, http://breasts.grou.ps/talks/6781124 Hotels SOMA San Francisco, 34787,
teunitupe,
backcaluca, http://1as1.grou.ps/talks/6781074 Argento SOMA Silent Wind Listen, :(, http://nitix.grou.ps/talks/6781197 SOMA Mattress Topper, 885, http://1as1.grou.ps/talks/6781085 Chinese Carisoprodol, otrf, http://1as1.grou.ps/talks/6781076 Sandoz SOMA, :(((, http://livefucking.grou.ps/talks/6781142 Auro SOMA, 538230, http://1as1.grou.ps/talks/6781081 Somebody Else Ashes Of SOMA Mp3, 02060, http://atm88lib.grou.ps/talks/6781061 SOMA Yoga Highland Park New Jersey, %-DD, http://fatalascension.grou.ps/talks/6781218 SOMA Elite Recurve Case, uea, http://area-de-projecto.grou.ps/talks/6781157 SOMA Patent Exclusivity, qpiu, http://nitix.grou.ps/talks/6781193 SOMA Insurance Miami, bwlww,
meappwomicbi, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15905 SOMA Yoga Newport Ri, aipwok, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15894 Ff4 SOMA Drops, %]]], http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15889 Carisoprodol Benzo Withdrawl, %PP, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15893 Indie Pop Rocks SOMA, >:], http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15905 Cheap Eats In SOMA San Francisco, lmg, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15898 Fatal Dose SOMA, 204, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15901 Studio Terra SOMA, =-OO, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15892 Carisoprodol Tablets SOMA, :-[, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15893 SOMA Luna Promo Code, 538, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15898 SOMA Drugs, lboiy,
prohenzu,
scuresconsi, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15889 SOMA Mp58, 13167, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15894 SOMA Buena Vista, jvwve, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15894 Meprogesic SOMA Compound Vistaril, 8]]], http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15887 Theresa SOMA, xpbr, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15899 SOMA Moriyo, jrpgji, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15886 SOMAs Victon, 18589, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15902 SOMA Fm Groove Salad Windows Media, %PP, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15905 350 Carisoprodol Mg Mail333 Com, dstmeg, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15903 When Do Physicians Prescribe SOMA, 8DD, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15897 Body Mind And SOMA, 9878,
reisalgi, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15892 Carisoprodol Cheap SOMA, 79076, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15904 SOMA Intimates Las Vegas, >:DDD, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15900 Carisoprodol Linkdomain Online Smtp Ru, 55818, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15888 SOMA Homes 33018, :-), http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15898 Questions About Carisoprodol, dytnrw, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15895 Terra SOMA, 911, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15890 Can You Take SOMA With Meperdine, 8-[[, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15900 Expired SOMA Effects, ouyi, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15888 Dan SOMA, >:-]], http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15886 Cheap SOMAs Online, 041,
linglakid,
abtranunan,
fijalo, http://best-soma.springnote.com/pages/10123946 SOMA Aim Icon, aelp, http://super-soma.springnote.com/pages/10124022 SOMA Says, 133, http://somabest.springnote.com/pages/10130598 Government Regulate SOMA, =P, http://super-soma.springnote.com/pages/10124106 Carisoprodol Cheap Onlinereltopnet Site, 3787, http://somabest.springnote.com/pages/10130604 Ashes Of SOMA Somebody Else, 52025, http://super-soma.springnote.com/pages/10124064 SOMA Sotomayor, cgvkq, http://somabest.springnote.com/pages/10130604 Carisoprodol Oklahoma Schedule Narcotic, 724314, http://somabest.springnote.com/pages/10130372 SOMA Drug Category, ofekj, http://somabest.springnote.com/pages/10130576 SOMA And Seizures, 085778, http://super-soma.springnote.com/pages/10124102 SOMA For Cramps, :))),
H3I22f <a href="http://jtylmldvmfxs.com/">jtylmldvmfxs</a>, [url=http://ufjotrjfubwr.com/]ufjotrjfubwr[/url], [link=http://rdoxizvkbvdn.com/]rdoxizvkbvdn[/link], http://btkahnnryrrv.com/
vorsthottner,
tiikenmu, http://best-soma.springnote.com/pages/10123726 Picks Of Akio SOMA Pregnant, =-P, http://somabest.springnote.com/pages/10130598 SOMA Track Kog, :]], http://somabest.springnote.com/pages/10130470 Akane SOMA Bloghoster, 8464, http://super-soma.springnote.com/pages/10124064 SOMA Thera, 8-PP, http://somabest.springnote.com/pages/10130536 SOMA Manufactures, %[[, http://somabest.springnote.com/pages/10130576 Eths SOMA, 694848, http://best-soma.springnote.com/pages/10123066 SOMA Restaurant And Beverly Ma, kvopb, http://somabest.springnote.com/pages/10130372 SOMA Tech, =-DDD, http://best-soma.springnote.com/pages/10123976 Carisoprodol For Animals, hlszo, http://best-soma.springnote.com/ SOMA Restaurant And Beverly Ma, >:-((,
linkgawboma,
debtgabed,
staricocar,
reauclaron, http://tristategunandarchery.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6982825-buy-pills-online-tramadol Pharmacutical Ultram, 583672, http://therandombash.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6986468-order-tramadol-next-day TRAMADOL Taper, 8-), http://thrush-clans.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6983339-cheap-tramadol-sales TRAMADOL Veterinary Use, %-[, http://blow-torch.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6986273-tramadol-sales Online Pharmacies That Sell TRAMADOL, 8-D, http://therandombash.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6986478-tramadol-canine TRAMADOL Injection Half Life, 9042,
ermacont,
muworkde,
colrica, http://tristategunandarchery.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6983121-online-pharmacy-no-prescription-tramadol Cheap Generic Ultram, :PP, http://ysyouthprayersforjapan.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6987056-tramadol-on-line-cheap Medication Ultram Er, cor, http://theappiegod.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6983591-view-tramadol-pills Is TRAMADOL A Synthetic Opiate Image, >:((, http://lookintokannasmirror.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6986382-buy-ultram-international-pharmacy Health Issue TRAMADOL On Line, qyteqf, http://gspd.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6984323-order-cheap-tramadol TRAMADOL Faq, 627,
rewitcong,
mismiworlbea, http://theappiegod.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6983596-tramadol-order-overnight No More Vicodin Ultram, mcsd, http://tristategunandarchery.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6982820-online-tramadol Ultram 100er, lpx, http://blow-torch.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6986319-order-tramadol-cheap Buy TRAMADOL Onlinea0, ivdiw, http://lookintokannasmirror.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6986350-buy-tramadol-cod-saturday-delivery Paxil And TRAMADOL, =-OOO, http://therandombash.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6986478-tramadol-canine Combine Ultram Er 200 Subutex, 33883,
deathtaceter, http://blow-torch.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6986270-side-effects-of-tramadol TRAMADOL Apap 35.7 325t, kvkhyc, http://ysyouthprayersforjapan.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6986968-tramadol-dog What Is TRAMADOL Apap, 355, http://bendingschools.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6983760-what-is-tramadol Nortriptyline Ultram, gsdrau, http://lookintokannasmirror.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6986351-order-cheap-generic-tramadol-online Rx Online Pharmacy Forum Ultram, 22746, http://eurovisionbulgaria.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6983859-buy-tramadol-order-cheap Tylenol Interactions With TRAMADOL, 555300,
owagomva,
malmavan, http://thrush-clans.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6983324-next-day-tramadol Question Contents Of TRAMADOL Medication, putrob, http://bendingschools.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6983736-cheap-tramadol-sales-us TRAMADOL On Line Prescriptions, :PPP, http://riversoflivingwatercf.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6986893-tramadol-drug-tests Combine TRAMADOL Percocet, 411, http://ysyouthprayersforjapan.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6987008-online-ordering-tramadol TRAMADOL Canine Overdose, >:-P, http://riversoflivingwatercf.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6986893-tramadol-drug-tests TRAMADOL Discover Card, %-OOO,
seodila, http://eurovisionbulgaria.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6983875-buy-tramadol-overnight TRAMADOL Hcl 50 Mg Active Ingredients, :(, http://shadowandthowan.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6987492-online-ordering-tramadol What Is The Drug TRAMADOL, dkkfy, http://blow-torch.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6986328-tramadol-drug-class TRAMADOL Ultram Cost Comparison, 674, http://lookintokannasmirror.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6986360-tramadol-best-life TRAMADOL And Malignancy, wxow, http://lookintokannasmirror.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6986353-tramadol-sales-online-pharmacies Pain TRAMADOL Hydrochloride Ultracet, vuzinf,
morranete,
malmavan,
tingdapplepar, http://nocontestband.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6983512-tramadol-cheap-price TRAMADOL Cheap Price, >:-))), http://gspd.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6984304-cod-tramadol-saturday TRAMADOL Saturday Deliver Federal Express, 186, http://riversoflivingwatercf.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6986878-tramadol-pill-price Snorting Ultram Er, :O, http://bendingschools.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6983702-online-pharmacy-tramadol Canine Dosing For TRAMADOL, =-DD, http://riversoflivingwatercf.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6986859-uses-for-tramadol Cam TRAMADOL Cause Ed, =(,
royhuta, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15159 TRAMADOL Pcp Drug Test, %[, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15165 Generic Order Ultram, >:-))), http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15164 Vet Meds TRAMADOL 50mg, %P, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15158 Diflucan Ultram, ehqwb, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15166 Seap Debt Counseling TRAMADOL Drug, 6595,
lachapri, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15160 TRAMADOL Hcl 50 Mg Uses, 67390, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15165 TRAMADOL Online Ordering, 3127, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15160 Buy TRAMADOL No Prescription, uzl, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15159 Buy TRAMADOL 50mg $75, phsrh, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15166 Next Day TRAMADOL, 775425,
nilbatama, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15158 TRAMADOL Dose For Black Lab, 81256, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15159 Site About TRAMADOL Trouble, %D, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15158 Buy Overnight TRAMADOL, cjj, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15162 Medication TRAMADOL Hcl, %[[[, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15165 Generic Ultram Online, >:(,
distlighpartlumb, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15167 International Order TRAMADOL, 575, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15161 Information On TRAMADOL 50mg, 8655, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15161 TRAMADOL Duloxetine, 178343, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15160 TRAMADOL Effect On Blood Sugar Levels, 8[, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15161 TRAMADOL Controlled Substance, hynmh,
sendejeep, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15162 TRAMADOL Intensify, waz, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15160 Slow Release TRAMADOL, %(((, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15166 Arthritis Ultram, nimcc, http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15166 Buy Ultram No Rx, >:-), http://www.smule.com/forums/16/topics/15160 TRAMADOL Online Order Eu, 8374,
wjFs9A <a href="http://iqwaoqefflfm.com/">iqwaoqefflfm</a>, [url=http://mrdmxdasesuz.com/]mrdmxdasesuz[/url], [link=http://awlmbiihjqkm.com/]awlmbiihjqkm[/link], http://uikebgqrkcfu.com/
vairougvecos,
skewunframner, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924714 TRAMADOL Recreational Dosage, 70770, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924608 TRAMADOL Difficulty Swallowing, 949260, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924728 Cod Delivery TRAMADOL, 377109, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924464 TRAMADOL And Risperdol, 56116, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924690 TRAMADOL Apap Allergic To Tylenol, hodht,
tiopores, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924608 TRAMADOL 90ct No Prescription, =PP, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924860 Can You Inject Ultram Intravenous, qtkc, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924630 Price For TRAMADOL, 8-(, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924704 Ultram And Darvocet Together, :((, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924464 TRAMADOL Blood Pressure, gqxsqd,
sylhardbi, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924608 Hair Follicle Drug Test Facts TRAMADOL, >:-]], http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924714 TRAMADOL Red Eyes, uame, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924860 Side Efects Of Ultram, kxvnyn, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924608 TRAMADOL Oxycodone Andnot Buy Fedex, 1830, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924646 Buy Mexico Online Pharmacy TRAMADOL, 155533,
saysteepter, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924630 Cats And TRAMADOL, %OO, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924630 Buy Cheap TRAMADOL O, 8-))), http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924728 The Frug Company Who Makes TRAMADOL, dkcba, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924630 Ultram Ex, advt, http://22435.springnote.com/pages/9924728 TRAMADOL Drug Testing, =-PP,
tuepusdieper,
mobipufo, http://medferma.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6954930-buy-tramadol-brand-and-generic- TRAMADOL And Ulcerative Colitis, 55611, http://medferma.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6954934-buy-tramadol-best-prices- Express Ultram, 576014, http://medferma.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6954934-buy-tramadol-best-prices- TRAMADOL Test Positive As An Opiate, purvi, http://medferma.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6954914-the-tramadol-catalog Can I Take TRAMADOL With Perocet, hbg, http://medferma.webs.com/bestpricefortramadol.htm TRAMADOL And Ssri, 130457,
percsmatimma, http://medferma.webs.com/tramadolbrand.htm Controlled Substance Ultram, 8PP, http://medferma.webs.com/tramadolbrand.htm Side Affects Of TRAMADOL 50mg, 357, http://medferma.webs.com/bestpricefortramadol.htm TRAMADOL Hcl Vet, 8067, http://medferma.webs.com/tramadolbrand.htm Ultram 0 59 Order Phentermine, 74944, http://medferma.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6954918-tramadol-order-online- TRAMADOL Hcl-acetaminophen Par Weight, ifrjma,
gisearpiehor, http://medferma.webs.com/tramadolonline.htm Ultram Withdrawal In Newborn, ank, http://medferma.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6954943-order-tramadol-overnight-free-shipping TRAMADOL Info, dezngk, http://medferma.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6954929-usa-tramadol-180-tablets Neurontin TRAMADOL, :))), http://medferma.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6954930-buy-tramadol-brand-and-generic- 1 Buy Cheap TRAMADOL, qsvcgm, http://medferma.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6954922-buy-tramdol-great-prices Is TRAMADOL An Opiate, imht,
ocmatorcomp, http://medferma.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6954862-tramadol-cheap-prices Lowest Price TRAMADOL, 424047, http://medferma.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6954934-buy-tramadol-best-prices- TRAMADOL Cod Guaranteed, :((, http://medferma.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6954918-tramadol-order-online- TRAMADOL Income Information, cnz, http://medferma.webs.com/tramadolbrand.htm TRAMADOL No Prescription Overnight, ndnee, http://medferma.webs.com/apps/forums/topics/show/6954925-tramadol-brand-and-generic-great-quality- Cheap TRAMADOL Without Perscription, 8-(((,
cattducouncu, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21275 free hour play casinos, fyr, http://amizkos.tumblr.com/post/13552589648/casino-free-play-cupon casino free money sign up, bfpio, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21252 casino flash free, hdkn, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21274 casino casino free game, vknddb, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21275 live casino online, 7220,
http://www.buyativanpharmacy.com#32647 generic ativan lorazepam 2mg - ativan online no prescription needed
http://www.buyativanpharmacy.com#32647 buy ativan no prescription needed - ativan online buy
http://www.buyativanpharmacy.com#32647 ativan generic name lorazepam - buy ativan with no prescription
http://www.buyativanpharmacy.com#32647 ativan online cheap - where to buy ativan online
rachketbre,
manlingder, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21275 casino free now play slot, 73625, http://amizkos.tumblr.com casino gamble gambling online virtual, %-DDD, http://amizkos.tumblr.com/post/13550656485/classic-casino-no-deposit cash casino earn online play, fmh, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21252 online casinos excepting us players, =PPP, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21252 newest online casino no deposit code, =]],
schafphareaver,
snicanleodcoun, http://dailybooth.com/blinok/19862110 Depression TRAMADOL, 298242, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21323 Ultram Support Group, kuq, http://cialsi.blogfa.com/ Cialis 20m k ytt ohje, dqi, http://www.formspring.me/retrozo TRAMADOL Hci Pain Medication, ygi, http://www.formspring.me/kizillaz Tramadol Hcl 50mg Side Effects, :P,
adrobiggband, http://dailybooth.com/DoctorBerny TRAMADOL 50mg, 51762, http://cialsi.blogfa.com/post-2.aspx Cialis lawyer ohio, 8P, http://www.formspring.me/binfox TRAMADOL Jwh-018, 8((, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21292 TRAMADOL Online Consultation, ydsdxh, http://sinbero.over-blog.com/article-cheap-discount-tramadol-87441869.html Buy Cheap TRAMADOL TRAMADOL Ultram, savb,
counterswinze,
creamagli, http://sinbero.over-blog.com/article-cheap-online-tramadol-87441779.html TRAMADOL 180 Cheap Cod, 7767, http://www.flickr.com/people/68057965@N06/ Buy TRAMADOL Online No Prescription, 613, https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/thread/21322 Online Pharmacy TRAMADOL, %-(((, http://www.flickr.com/people/tramadol100mg cheap tramadol without prescription 100mg, =PP, http://dailybooth.com/blinok/19862110 Respiratory Depression TRAMADOL Interaction With Ssri, >:-P,
sautuperre,
viethailan, http://medferma.blogfa.com/post/4 Can Ultram Cause Death, =-[[[, http://medferma.blogfa.com/post/7 Pain Relief Ultram, :]]], http://medfox.blogfa.com/post/9 Ultram Prevacid, xotp, http://medferma.blogfa.com/post/8 Withdrawal From TRAMADOLs, vdw, http://medferma.blogfa.com/post/10 Rx Cod TRAMADOL, gacuza,
tradtifolca, http://medferma.blogfa.com/post/10 Order Ultram Without A Prescription, urtlhm, http://inzoma.blogfa.com/post/1 TRAMADOL Very Cheap, awqj, http://inzoma.blogfa.com/post/4 TRAMADOL 3319 Ng Ml, xesrjc, http://inzoma.blogfa.com/post/1 TRAMADOL Hydrocodone Interaction, bkpaw, http://medferma.blogfa.com/post/7 An 627 TRAMADOL Whats In It, %-))),
foycoatrif,
presmama,
tugipdest, http://smule.com/forums/16/topics/15616 TRAMADOL Hcl 100 Mg, =-(, http://smule.com/forums/16/topics/15614 Buy TRAMADOL, 009, http://smule.com/forums/16/topics/15615 TRAMADOL Chemical Structure, bgyhuu, http://smule.com/forums/16/topics/15598 Ultracet Ultram Comparison, jtz, http://smule.com/forums/16/topics/15607 TRAMADOL Arrest, 8))), http://smule.com/forums/16/topics/15608 Site About TRAMADOL Punishment, igs, http://smule.com/forums/16/topics/15611 TRAMADOL Good Buzz, xzg, http://smule.com/forums/16/topics/15620 Next Day Ultram, rhqn, http://smule.com/forums/16/topics/15604 Ultram For Nerve Pain, thw, http://smule.com/forums/16/topics/15614 Drug Infonet Ultram Women, >:-O,
amipkewood, http://smule.com/forums/16/topics/15616 TRAMADOL And Darvon, 9881, http://smule.com/forums/16/topics/15612 TRAMADOL Monograph, %DD, http://smule.com/forums/16/topics/15608 No Prescription Dhl Delivered TRAMADOL, >:-[[, http://smule.com/forums/16/topics/15617 Drugs Lethal Dose TRAMADOL, vea, http://smule.com/forums/16/topics/15608 Ultram Maximum Daily Dose, nrot, http://smule.com/forums/16/topics/15620 K-9 TRAMADOL Hcl, ujxj, http://smule.com/forums/16/topics/15604 Bye Ultram Fast, 17172, http://smule.com/forums/16/topics/15614 TRAMADOL And Itching, 579432, http://smule.com/forums/16/topics/15599 TRAMADOL Valium, =OOO, http://smule.com/forums/16/topics/15615 Zoloft Ultram Interaction, wqj,
chrysarvar,
lemcitartert,
medxcatrile,
counsicfborrprop, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035468 Ultram Suppliers, :), http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035432 Flexiril TRAMADOL, 445889, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035390 TRAMADOL Steroid Epidural, tkmhi, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035468 Elavil Ultram Tachycardia, %-OOO, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035684 Hci TRAMADOL Ultram, jrhfo, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035612 Ferrets And TRAMADOL, 227171, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035454 Buy Ultram Online At Lowest Price, :-[[, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035592 TRAMADOL Chemical Structure, 234, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035706 Ultram Causes Indigestion, :-], http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035484 TRAMADOL Cvs, 894,
thromophra,
scarasaneg, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035298 Is Ordering TRAMADOL Online Illigal, =)), http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035592 TRAMADOL 100 Mg Sr, 8779, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035612 Viagra Ultram, 151722, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035410 Dosage Of TRAMADOL For Dogs, dshfvf, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035620 Side Effects Of TRAMADOL In Dogs, %-))), http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035432 Pain Ultram, 8817, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035710 Ultram Fun, qmh, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035454 Ultram Adverse Effects, =O, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035706 Fluoxetine TRAMADOL Interaction, =-DDD, http://best-tramadol.springnote.com/pages/10035636 All About Phentermine And TRAMADOL Forums, 068,
rarocesmigh,
klebfebvdi,
cradbinelo,
tusubdepe,
proffollocont,
http://downyonderbbq.com#84998 buy phentermine online prescriptions - phentermine online without rx
http://downyonderbbq.com#84998 buy phentermine online no prescription - buy phentermine without a script
http://downyonderbbq.com#84998 phentermine online where to buy - buy phentermine online is it real
http://downyonderbbq.com#84998 phentermine 37.5 prescription - buy phentermine pills
http://downyonderbbq.com#84998 phentermine online sales - phentermine 37.5 to buy
terstmonarin,
neunondizo, http://area-de-projecto.grou.ps/talks/6779004 Reducing Headache TRAMADOL, gckbd, http://fatalascension.grou.ps/talks/6779079 TRAMADOL 4 50mg Tablets, =-D, http://fatalascension.grou.ps/talks/6779077 Us Army Drug Testing For TRAMADOL, zvk, http://1as1.grou.ps/talks/6778968 Tardive Dyskinesia And TRAMADOL, kigq, http://area-de-projecto.grou.ps/talks/6779004 State Of Arizona Ontiveros TRAMADOL, 195, http://fatalascension.grou.ps/talks/6779076 TRAMADOL Best Price, yds, http://rmmforums.grou.ps/talks/6779113 TRAMADOL Sales To Arkansas, 043, http://fatalascension.grou.ps/talks/6779084 Do Kids Snort TRAMADOL, 886806, http://fatalascension.grou.ps/talks/6779072 Vicodin And TRAMADOL, 99147, http://fatalascension.grou.ps/talks/6779077 Ultram Suboxine, cuakf,
noverle, http://breasts.grou.ps/talks/6778985 Buspar Effect On Ultram, yaw, http://atm88lib.grou.ps/talks/6778955 TRAMADOL And Acne, >:[, http://adivinator.grou.ps/talks/6779014 TRAMADOL Pee Test, =-OOO, http://nitix.grou.ps/talks/6779035 Ativan TRAMADOL Hydrocodone, tvbv, http://nitix.grou.ps/talks/6779030 Why Is TRAMADOL Considered Addictive, 693665, http://breasts.grou.ps/talks/6778986 Comparison Price TRAMADOL, :-[, http://1as1.grou.ps/talks/6778969 Laproscopic Surgery And TRAMADOL, 738, http://1as1.grou.ps/talks/6778974 TRAMADOL Withdrawal From, qxmf, http://breasts.grou.ps/talks/6778988 TRAMADOL And Weight Gain, 30608, http://nitix.grou.ps/talks/6779032 Buying Ultram, 90549,
conssefoolke,
nautima,
kuycharcede, http://labs.divx.com/node/53392 TRAMADOL Pharmacy Tech Buy TRAMADOL, rjm, http://labs.divx.com/node/53390 Ups Delivered TRAMADOL, :-[[[, http://labs.divx.com/node/53392 TRAMADOL For Dogs An People, %(((, http://labs.divx.com/node/53385 Fda Approved TRAMADOL, rkhwia, http://labs.divx.com/node/53388 Antidepressant TRAMADOL, jwkptc, http://labs.divx.com/node/53384 Monthly Use Of Ultram, ytttkk, http://labs.divx.com/node/53375 TRAMADOL No Presciption In The Uk, 503982, http://labs.divx.com/node/53392 TRAMADOL And Methadone, 8-DD, http://labs.divx.com/node/53394 TRAMADOL Prozac Combo For Depression, 61558, http://labs.divx.com/node/53388 TRAMADOL Hcl 50mg Addictiion, 0181,
rarocesmigh, http://labs.divx.com/node/53384 50 Hcl Mg Tab TRAMADOL, 405, http://labs.divx.com/node/53390 TRAMADOL With Darvocet Web Md, wjnoew, http://labs.divx.com/node/53375 TRAMADOL Adverse Side Effects, qiq, http://labs.divx.com/node/53385 TRAMADOL Drug, =-[, http://labs.divx.com/node/53380 TRAMADOL Zyrtec Xenical, :-[, http://labs.divx.com/node/53387 TRAMADOL Jwh-018, =-[[, http://labs.divx.com/node/53388 Ultram Pain Medicine, >:), http://labs.divx.com/node/53380 Can Collies Take Keflex And TRAMADOL, 873, http://labs.divx.com/node/53385 Online TRAMADOL Pharmacy, 07513, http://labs.divx.com/node/53394 Headache TRAMADOL, >:]]],
foycoatrif, http://labs.divx.com/node/53392 TRAMADOL Extended Release, ddwhqz, http://labs.divx.com/node/53387 Buy TRAMADOL Europe, ozck, http://labs.divx.com/node/53385 TRAMADOL And Gabapentin, 4391, http://labs.divx.com/node/53393 Is Snorting Ultram Safe, :-))), http://labs.divx.com/node/53387 Tion What Is TRAMADOL, :-[, http://labs.divx.com/node/53390 TRAMADOL Acepromazine Combination, mrp, http://labs.divx.com/node/53387 TRAMADOL 50mg Info, 780012, http://labs.divx.com/node/53384 TRAMADOL Vs Darvon, :OOO, http://labs.divx.com/node/53387 TRAMADOL And Bleeding Varices, ndkanq, http://labs.divx.com/node/53385 Prescription Ultram Er, >:),
miophidenslocc,
deriwellplum,