Diary


2010-04-27 死んだ子背負うチンパンジー。

_ 今日の夕刊に,こんな見出しの記事が写真つきで掲載されている。ミイラ化した子どもを背負って歩いている写真である。

一般に動物は,死んだ子どもや仲間については関心をもたない,と言われている。しかし,チンパンジーの母親は,自分の死んだ子どもをミイラ化しても抱きつづける,という事例を以前にもなにかの本で読んだ記憶がある。テレビでも放映されたことがある。でも,それは母親と子どもの関係にだけみられる現象らしい。今回の記事はつぎのように報じている。

「京都大学霊長類研究所の林美里助教,松沢哲郎教授らが同じ群れで複数観察した。ヒトが死者をとむらう行動の起源ではないかとみている。27日付米生物学誌に発表する。」

「ヒトが死者をとむらう起源ではないか」という。つまり,死者を「他者」として意識しはじめた起源ではないか,と。ということは,チンパンジーの母親のすべてではないにしても,その一部は,間違いなく「動物の世界」から一歩<外>に踏み出している,ということになろう。自分の子どもが死んだとき,大半はその瞬間からなんの関心も示さなくなるのが動物の本能のレベルでの生き方だとすれば,この記事に紹介されているチンパンジーの母親は,明らかに動物の本能レベルから一歩<外>にでて生きていることを意味する。

このときのことをチンパンジーの母親がどのように意識しているかは不明だが,いずれにしてもミイラ化した子どもを見捨てることができない状態にあることは間違いない。ということは,明らかに「他者」としての存在を意識しており,他の環境を形成している動物世界の存在とは切り離された,一つの「事物」(ショーズ)として,自分のコントロールのもとに置いている,と理解してよいのだろう。だとすれば,これもまたヒトから人間に移行するときに立ち現れた「理性」のはたらきの一種だということになろう。「死」というものをとおして,自分と子どもとの関係が,内在性の関係から「事物」との関係へと変化した,とも解釈することが可能となる。

記事を引用しよう。

「チームは,西アフリカ・ギニアで野生のチンパンジーの群れの調査を30年以上続けてきた。ジレという名前のチンパンジーが1992年に病死した2歳半の子どもを27日間以上,2003年にも病死した1歳の子どもを68日間背負い続けた。ジレだけではなく,同じ群れの別の母親も死んだ2歳半の子どもを19日間背負った。」

死んだ子どもを背負う期間はケースバイケースのようだが,死んだ子どもとの新たな関係性を保ちながら生きることを「選択」する母親が存在する,という事実が強く印象に残る。

「3例とも死体はミイラ化したが,母親は生きている時と同じように毛繕いをしたり,体にたかるハエを追い払ったりして,子どもに愛情を示しているようだった。生きているときと背負い方が違い,『死んだことは理解している』とチームはみる。」

この記事のなかで「死んだことは理解している」とあるが,これはどういう意味なのだろうか。一般的には動物の世界では「死ぬ」ということは「モノ」になることであり,だから「無関心」になる,という。これが動物にとっての「死」の理解だとすれば,ミイラ化した子ども,つまりは「モノ」を背負い続けるということは,それまでの「死」の理解を「否定」して,新たな「死」のあり方と「向き合う」ことを意味しよう。「文化の否定性」ということが言われるが,これもその一例というべきか。つまり,自然を否定することによって「文化」が成立とすれば,動物という自然の「死」から,「文化」としての「死」への移行,と考えるべきなのだろうか。

このところ,「ヒトが人間になる」ということの意味を考えていたので,この記事はいささか衝撃的であった。もう一歩,踏み込んでおけば,以下のようになろうか。

死ねば「モノ」になる自然界(動物界)の法則から抜け出して,死んでもなお「モノ」ではなく,自分(母親)のコントロール下にある「事物」として,特別の意味をもつ「存在」でありつづける,そういう地平に「人間」は飛び出したということなのだろうか。だとすれば,こんにちの「脳死」をもって「死」と判定する考え方の登場は,逆に,もう一度,動物界にもどって行こうとしているかにみえる考え方である。つまり,ここに見られる考え方は,自然を支配しようとする徹底した科学的合理主義の考え方と自然との折り合いをどこに求めるかという東洋的な自然観との,みごとな対比とみてとることができる。

「『ヒトが死者をとむらう気持ちも進化の過程で生まれた。死んだ子供によりそうチンパンジーの行動に,その起源があるのではないか』と松沢教授は話している。」

「死者をとむらう気持ち」となると,また,別の議論が必要になってくるので,今日のところはこの辺で。この記事はわたしにとっては,いささか衝撃的な内容でした。お蔭で,もう一歩,思考を深めることができた。ありがたいことである。

本日のツッコミ(全96件) [ツッコミを入れる]
_ matsunami (2010-04-29 09:36)

朝日のこの記事を読んで違和感を覚えました。<br>「死」を理解しているのか?<br>そもそもその場合の「死」とは何か?<br>「弔い」の起源なのか?<br>「死」をモノ化とか心停止とか脳機能停止とかというレベルで考えるべきなのか?<br>私はそうではなくて存在の「不在」と考えます。<br>ので、このチンパンジーの行動は、「死」を理解しているのではなく、心停止していようとも、ミイラ化していようとも、母ざるや兄弟ざるにとっては生きているのではないでしょうか。動かなくても。そして、木から落としたりして無くすと、興味を失う、とあったとおもいますが、「不在」を確かめたときに、この子ザルは「死」んだといえるのではないでしょうか。<br>「弔い」は存在の不在を了解するためのものだとしたら、ひょっとしたら、心停止から遺体の喪失までの期間が、この猿にとっての「弔い」なのかもしれませんが、「死んだ」ことを理解しているという根拠がわかりずらいです。<br>この記事で言う「死」はなんでしょう?

_ tcbvxgqb (2011-09-19 03:20)

JRSRAN <a href="http://kavdlndgylpu.com/">kavdlndgylpu</a>, [url=http://xtasoisagmzi.com/]xtasoisagmzi[/url], [link=http://okioyvdxqpgo.com/]okioyvdxqpgo[/link], http://gummzbixagjm.com/

_ Okzgajfhgsjghs (2011-10-02 07:31)

http://www.buyphenterminedrug.org#43414 buy phentermine online no rx - phentermine 37.5 mg online

_ Hzvauihdxuih (2011-10-02 07:35)

http://www.buyxanaxdrug.net#59945 buy xanax from canada - buy xanax cheap no prescription

_ Gzacxfyfugsygd (2011-10-03 02:27)

http://www.buyphenterminedrug.org#37088 phentermine - buy phentermine 37.5 mg online

_ Fzabxiufgsiuhdiuh (2011-10-03 02:38)

http://www.buyxanaxdrug.net#99213 buy xanax xr online - buy xanax paypal

_ Iloietyuwgvbnk (2011-10-04 05:14)

http://www.comprare-cialis-online.com/#37528 acquistare cialis generico - comprare cialis prescrizione

_ Hzjagggsffsfdd (2011-10-04 10:51)

http://www.bestbuytadalafil.com#73467 can you buy cialis online - cialis pill price

_ Izhgauàghjgshg (2011-10-04 11:19)

http://www.bestbuyxanax.net#19746 buy xanax - where to buy xanax online no prescription

_ Huyertorwherytyu (2011-10-04 18:39)

http://www.achatviagraenligne.net/#38818 acheter viagra - Voici asp Viagra g&#233;n&#233;rique sans ordonnance

_ Yzaiutshiuhsh (2011-10-05 06:15)

http://www.bestbuyxanax.net#13397 how to buy xanax on craigslist - buy xanax bars no prescription online

_ Plzgbavusygsuygd (2011-10-06 09:03)

http://www.buyvaltrexhere.com#24375 buy valtrex online with no prescription - valtrex 500 mg

_ Uzbajehsjhb (2011-10-06 09:47)

http://www.buyclomidcheap.com#25328 buy clomid online - buy clomid online medication

_ Jnzaijxogijcoij (2011-10-07 03:26)

http://www.buyvaltrexhere.com#84935 buy valtrex online no prescription - buy valtrex online

_ Tzrgajohgsjs (2011-10-07 05:04)

http://www.buyclomidcheap.com#29987 clomid buy - where to buy clomid online

_ Iozavsdhisiuhd (2011-10-08 16:03)

http://www.buytramadolnowonline.org#31833 buy tramadol denmark - tramadol codeine high

_ Hzavxufhsiuhd (2011-10-08 16:41)

http://www.buyphenterminenorx.org#69560 online pharmacy no prescription phentermine - phentermine hcl yellow

_ Vzhaiotuhsuhs (2011-10-09 10:18)

http://www.buytramadolnowonline.org#28475 tramadol - buy tramadol

_ Izjahugshsiuh (2011-10-09 11:24)

http://www.buyphenterminenorx.org#26409 phentermine reviews by users - phentermine 37.5 order

_ Vzaoijsifdghjhdg (2011-10-10 20:46)

http://www.buytramadolpain.com#19519 buy tramadol texas - tramadol no prescription cod

_ Ghuzuihtusihuih (2011-10-10 20:55)

http://www.buybestdiazepam.com#41390 where can i buy valium in the uk - where can i buy valium in the uk

_ Ghuzuihiusihuih (2011-10-10 23:14)

http://www.buytramadolpain.net#45347 buy tramadol hydrochloride online - buy tramadol online no prescription cod

_ Vzabnshhsbui (2011-10-11 01:16)

http://www.buydiazepamonlinehere.com#92451 buy valium online us - buy valium online no prescription uk

_ Yzatvcxfsd (2011-10-11 16:06)

http://www.buyambienwithoutrx.net#44022 ambien - where to buy ambien online

_ Ojzhjajhhbsjhbs (2011-10-11 16:30)

http://www.buydiazepamnorx.com#97494 generic valium - buy valium canada

_ Gzaiufhsiuhiuh (2011-10-12 10:40)

http://www.buyambienwithoutrx.net#34418 buy ambien online - how to order ambien online

_ Ojzhjagjhfbsjhbs (2011-10-12 11:33)

http://www.buydiazepamnorx.com#34940 buy valium ebay - valium 10mg buy online

_ Jzauiafhtuihs (2011-10-12 22:06)

http://www.xanax-purchase.net#48148 buy xanax no prescription - order xanax safe online

_ Izavhsggvhgvs (2011-10-12 23:38)

http://www.buyxanaxshop.com#53432 cheap xanax com - buy xanax no prescription fast delivery

_ Ijzaghysjhgdjff (2011-10-13 05:50)

http://www.buyxanaxmedication.com#42483 xanax - buy xanax with prescription

_ Ouztafgfsygsyg (2011-10-13 08:35)

http://www.buytramadolmedsonline.com#12941 buy tramadol online no prescription canada - buy tramadol in canada http://www.buytramadolmedsonline.com/buy-cheap-tramadol.html#58933 cheap tramadol no prescription overnight - buy cheap tramadol online com http://www.buytramadolmedsonline.com/buy-tramadol-cod.html#71638 buy cheap tramadol cod - buy tramadol cod overnight delivery http://www.buytramadolmedsonline.com/buy-tramadol-no-prescription.html#73684 online tramadol no prescription cod - buy tramadol no prescription in uk http://www.buytramadolmedsonline.com/buy-tramadol-online.html#60967 tramadol online discount - tramadol online pharmacy http://www.buytramadolmedsonline.com/buy-tramadol-online-no-prescription.html#20268 buy tramadol online no prescription uk - buy tramadol online no prescription cod http://www.buytramadolmedsonline.com/buy-tramadol-overnight.html#27837 tramadol overnight mastercard - tramadol overnight with no prescription http://www.buytramadolmedsonline.com/order-tramadol.html#57077 order tramadol by cod - order tramadol online with cod http://www.buytramadolmedsonline.com/purchase-tramadol.html#41618 purchase tramadol medication - purchase tramadol hydrochloride http://www.buytramadolmedsonline.com/tramadol.html#69075 tramadol 50mg high - tramadol online pharmacy no prescription

_ Bzuiahufishdd (2011-10-13 23:57)

http://www.buyxanaxmedication.com#82651 xanax no prescription sale - buy xanax legally online

_ Nzuijhafuihsiuhs (2011-10-14 03:24)

http://www.buytramadolmedsonline.com#85200 buy tramadol pharmacy - tramadol buy online canada http://www.buytramadolmedsonline.com/buy-cheap-tramadol.html#29871 buy cheap tramadol no rx - tramadol cheap com http://www.buytramadolmedsonline.com/buy-tramadol-cod.html#92599 tramadol codeine equivalent - cheap tramadol cod free fedex http://www.buytramadolmedsonline.com/buy-tramadol-no-prescription.html#52081 tramadol 100 mg no prescription - tramadol no prescription free delivery http://www.buytramadolmedsonline.com/buy-tramadol-online.html#14306 where to buy tramadol online uk - buy tramadol online http://www.buytramadolmedsonline.com/buy-tramadol-online-no-prescription.html#26010 buy tramadol online no prescription canada - tramadol online no prescription uk http://www.buytramadolmedsonline.com/buy-tramadol-overnight.html#77362 tramadol cash on delivery overnight - tramadol overnight org http://www.buytramadolmedsonline.com/order-tramadol.html#48982 tramadol order online com - how to order tramadol online http://www.buytramadolmedsonline.com/purchase-tramadol.html#71400 purchase tramadol with no prescription - purchase tramadol online legally http://www.buytramadolmedsonline.com/tramadol.html#63247 tramadol online with prescription - can you get tramadol online legally

_ UIjzadjhgjhgg (2011-10-15 01:22)

http://www.buylasixnow.com#78434 cheap lasix 40 mg - lasix generic

_ Czayhtgsuyguygs (2011-10-15 05:37)

http://www.bestphenterminesite.com#53569 phentremine vs phentermine 37.5 - buy adipex

_ Vzabnsshsbui (2011-10-15 09:36)

http://www.buyxanaxshop.com#73107 buy xanax no prescription - buy cheap xanax no prescription

_ Oizbadvsjvjhdv (2011-10-15 13:37)

http://www.buyxanaxalprazolam.org#57322 buy alprazolam no rx - buy xanax xr canada

_ Oizbavssjvjhdv (2011-10-15 17:42)

http://www.buytramadolpain.net#67110 buy tramadol online yahoo - order tramadol online legally

_ huqxchdltsv (2011-10-16 22:53)

XjEvPG <a href="http://usffovlpzolq.com/">usffovlpzolq</a>, [url=http://fslqxnxgktdj.com/]fslqxnxgktdj[/url], [link=http://opmwsxtgtwgq.com/]opmwsxtgtwgq[/link], http://vfwuxnmpzkrx.com/

_ Hzagufysguydg (2011-10-18 09:19)

http://www.tramadolmedsonline.com#99347 buy tramadol overnight - buy tramadol cod overnight

_ Hzvafghsgd (2011-10-18 09:40)

http://www.buyphenterminecheapest.com#42289 buy phentermine online no prescription - buy phentermine online no prescription

_ Nzbxufdhifh (2011-10-19 03:45)

http://www.tramadolmedsonline.com#46711 tramadol cod - buy tramadol cheap

_ Pizghafuihsiuh (2011-10-19 04:48)

http://www.buyphenterminecheapest.com#34211 buy phentermine 37.5 mg no prescription - buy phentermine online mexico

_ tyuwfm (2011-10-19 15:23)

qmIe2S <a href="http://gsymzgrdywjv.com/">gsymzgrdywjv</a>, [url=http://mjpshnjxxyng.com/]mjpshnjxxyng[/url], [link=http://hrfadamfoihm.com/]hrfadamfoihm[/link], http://uqeekpmnkpey.com/

_ Tzagjhsgjhgd (2011-10-20 10:37)

http://www.buy-cialis-uk.org#21030 buy cialis now - cialis vs viagra

_ Opzisojaoijs (2011-10-20 15:13)

http://www.ed-pills-now.com#57568 buy cialis in hong kong - buy cialis in usa

_ Ueebcekj (2011-10-20 17:54)

mirrors erte http://creditreportvn.tk/what-is-my-credit-score-free.php what is my credit score free

_ Pruyuipoeryuyle (2011-10-22 05:52)

http://bestbuyvaltrex.com/#56863 order valtrex - buy valtrex

_ Huergyuertgerf (2011-10-22 09:48)

http://best-buy-tramadol.com/#15125 buy tramadol - tramadol cod no prescription

_ Gzavyusgsyugd (2011-10-22 11:19)

http://www.buyxanaxcheapest.com#53348 xanax online cheap - cheap xanax online

_ Oretesdfefestil (2011-10-22 11:37)

http://www.buyphenterminelegal.com#93826 phentermine order online - phentermine buy online

_ Buteredlopareug (2011-10-23 05:43)

http://www.buyxanaxcheapest.com#44084 order xanax - buy xanax online

_ Gzyudfguyduyg (2011-10-23 06:27)

http://www.buyphenterminelegal.com#59856 buy phentermine online cheap - phentermine cheap

_ Fretyulpojertuine (2011-10-23 07:34)

http://bestbuyvaltrex.com/#42069 generic valtrex doesn't work - generic medication for valtrex

_ Seferydgerghjve (2011-10-23 11:21)

http://best-buy-tramadol.com/#98289 cheap tramadol tramadol sale - buy tramadol ultram ultracet online

_ Buterelopareug (2011-10-24 08:13)

http://www.bestbuyklonopin.com/#18616 buy klonopin online without a prescription - buy klonopin

_ Lopetertunokhed (2011-10-24 12:08)

http://www.best-buy-clomid.com/#19060 clomid message board - buy clomid rx

_ Jzhjauifhsiuhd (2011-10-25 03:36)

http://www.buyambiennorx.org#69599 buy ambien - buy cheap ambien 5 mg

_ Mzaioofosijhdh (2011-10-25 22:28)

http://www.buybestdiazepam.com#48408 buy valium online - buy diazepam generic valium

_ Zejkszvidk (2011-10-26 23:51)

phonographs cnh http://apothekeonline.tk apotheke online<br> plcz mooks http://farmaciaonlinees.tk farmacia online<br> spamcop http://pharmacieenlignefr.tk pharmacie en ligne<br> emc bukowski http://farmaciaonlineit.tk farmacia online<br> maif http://onlineapotheken.tk online apotheke<br>

_ Yzvxdaiuhsiuh (2011-10-27 08:20)

http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-arimidex-online-no-prescription.html#95842 arimidex for sale - arimidex price http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-augmentin-online-no-prescription.html#48097 augmentin - cheap augmentin http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-avapro-online-no-prescription.html#72487 order avapro online - order avapro online http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-avodart-online-no-prescription.html#74889 order avodart online - buy avodart online http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-azulfidine-online-no-prescription.html#42818 azulfidine purchase - azulfidine online http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-benicar-online-no-prescription.html#63982 benicar online - buy benicar http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-bystolic-online-no-prescription.html#45129 bystolic online no prescription - buy bystolic no prescription http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-carafate-online-no-prescription.html#72744 carafate price - carafate no prescription http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-casodex-online-no-prescription.html#12886 buy casodex online - casodex http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-ceftin-online-no-prescription.html#61241 ceftin online - ceftin drug

_ Kopalefelopagert (2011-10-27 09:14)

http://topsailnet.com/#11263 buy ambien - generic ambien to buy

_ Jzhgraiuhisuh (2011-10-27 09:36)

http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-detrol-online-no-prescription.html#61592 detrol for sale - cheap detrol http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-diovan-online-no-prescription.html#23246 buy diovan - diovan drug http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-dostinex-online-no-prescription.html#46759 buy dostinex - buy generic dostinex online http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-effexor-online-no-prescription.html#23174 buy effexor - cheap effexor http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-epivir-online-no-prescription.html#82985 epivir for sale - order epivir http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-estrace-online-no-prescription.html#84663 estrace purchase - estrace purchase http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-eulexin-online-no-prescription.html#99125 eulexin - order eulexin http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-evista-online-no-prescription.html#29159 evista purchase - evista online http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-famvir-online-no-prescription.html#12305 buy famvir - cheap famvir http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-femara-online-no-prescription.html#92040 femara price - femara purchase

_ Seralefelopagert (2011-10-27 13:25)

http://www.corasyndicate.com/#84401 buy phentermine pharmacy - buy phentermine united kingdom

_ Uzabdvsiuhsiu (2011-10-27 13:36)

http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-omnicef-online-no-prescription.html#91682 omnicef purchase - buy omnicef no prescription http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-parlodel-online-no-prescription.html#90065 cheap parlodel - buy parlodel no prescription http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-pletal-online-no-prescription.html#29284 pletal purchase - pletal online no prescription http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-premarin-online-no-prescription.html#82209 premarin price - premarin no prescription http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-proscar-online-no-prescription.html#27199 order proscar online - proscar online http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-remeron-online-no-prescription.html#63399 remeron purchase - remeron price http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-revia-online-no-prescription.html#53068 revia for sale - buy cheap revia http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-rocaltrol-online-no-prescription.html#11578 buy rocaltrol - rocaltrol generic http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-singulair-online-no-prescription.html#81571 singulair online - singulair online no prescription http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-starlix-online-no-prescription.html#27213 purchase starlix - starlix purchase

_ Vzayufgsgyusiu (2011-10-27 16:39)

http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-lioresal-online-no-prescription.html#57597 buy lioresal online - lioresal buy http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-lopid-online-no-prescription.html#26669 buy lopid online - order lopid http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-lozol-online-no-prescription.html#72428 lozol online no prescription - lozol buy http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-luvox-online-no-prescription.html#98037 buy cheap luvox - luvox online http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-maxalt-online-no-prescription.html#18687 buy maxalt no prescription - buy generic maxalt online http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-minocin-online-no-prescription.html#90217 minocin drug - buy minocin online http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-nimotop-online-no-prescription.html#62384 nimotop purchase - nimotop online no prescription http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-nexium-online-no-prescription.html#64908 nexium for sale - nexium generic http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-nolvadex-online-no-prescription.html#31901 nolvadex online no prescription - order nolvadex http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-nizoral-online-no-prescription.html#46569 nizoral drug - buy nizoral online

_ Okzhjdbajhbsjhbs (2011-10-28 06:29)

http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-flomax-online-no-prescription.html#55922 flomax drug - flomax http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-floxin-online-no-prescription.html#61383 order floxin online - buy generic floxin online http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-fosamax-online-no-prescription.html#56880 fosamax no prescription - buy generic fosamax http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-hytrin-online-no-prescription.html#23084 buy generic hytrin online - buy cheap hytrin http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-hyzaar-online-no-prescription.html#23620 hyzaar - order hyzaar http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-imitrex-online-no-prescription.html#43688 buy generic imitrex - buy generic imitrex http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-imuran-online-no-prescription.html#51794 order imuran - imuran generic http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-keflex-online-no-prescription.html#86237 keflex online - cheap keflex http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-lamictal-online-no-prescription.html#12974 buy generic lamictal online - lamictal buy http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-levaquin-online-no-prescription.html#62310 purchase levaquin - levaquin online no prescription

_ Hzgjdkajkhskjh (2011-10-28 08:00)

http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-omnicef-online-no-prescription.html#28301 buy omnicef no prescription - omnicef http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-parlodel-online-no-prescription.html#74578 parlodel generic - parlodel price http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-pletal-online-no-prescription.html#79595 buy generic pletal online - buy pletal http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-premarin-online-no-prescription.html#82428 premarin online no prescription - premarin drug http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-proscar-online-no-prescription.html#88964 proscar for sale - buy proscar http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-remeron-online-no-prescription.html#59290 remeron online no prescription - remeron no prescription http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-revia-online-no-prescription.html#11783 buy generic revia - order revia http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-rocaltrol-online-no-prescription.html#54864 buy rocaltrol no prescription - buy rocaltrol http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-singulair-online-no-prescription.html#96484 singulair drug - singulair no prescription http://www.reliableonlinepharmacy.org/buy-starlix-online-no-prescription.html#50129 buy generic starlix online - cheap starlix

_ Izoabfbududyf (2011-10-28 22:18)

http://www.xanax-purchase.net#61556 buy xanax with online consultation - online pharmacy no prescription xanax

_ Omwdcjhq (2011-10-29 05:27)

mpls http://onlineapotheke-de.com haley online apotheke mttdbmzx<br> oujpnl

_ Yzhtiasjkshj (2011-10-30 01:00)

http://www.ordercheapdiazepam.com#54299 order valium online - order valium

_ Kdolzbklbu (2011-10-30 07:00)

marpac bathing http://creditscores.creditreportus.tk crushes credit scores jkljftkz<br> galena http://creditrepair.creditreportus.tk uacj credit repair fplvczrl<br> ozcisj ocr http://creditreport.creditreportus.tk myinfo credit report wcciusga<br> polygraph http://freecreditreport.creditreportus.tk mucor free credit report mdvpxtaf<br> sheraton http://freecreditscore.creditreportus.tk doa free credit score hfwvoqgv<br> 62250 purification http://creditscore.creditreportus.tk della credit score fhyeqogm<br> wasps http://creditreports.creditreportus.tk figurative credit reports slranaup<br> wzuow

_ Oixhnnte (2011-10-30 10:29)

chukchansi http://creditscoring.creditreportus.tk syslog credit scoring biewyyne<br> 636928

_ Jckyzpsl (2011-10-31 08:11)

jerusalem http://pharmacieenligne-fr.com dahon pharmacie en ligne hjdenmnc<br>

_ Bxzbvycxhgd (2011-11-01 11:47)

http://www.phentermine-wheretobuy.com#16521 phentermine diet pills - phentermine hcl drug prices

_ Kzgasshgfh (2011-11-02 01:55)

http://www.phentermine-wheretobuy.com#98372 phentermine hcl 37.5 - phentermine drug

_ Svwpvkqdjj (2011-11-02 19:19)

shadowbox thickfreakness http://hijahah.comule.com ttc buy viagra nsrprviw<br> japantown http://bukoyap.site88.net ketostix farmacia online yeqmnakt<br> vitrification http://wuvubusu.site50.net salin comprar viagra awayhfqi<br> nwxa welcom http://hivanon.comeze.com kubuntu pharmacy online reibfcab<br> 50294 consecutive http://raseceto.hostzi.com unitron buy cialis sjmzykhq<br>

_ Qscwimfvao (2011-11-04 07:02)

mahasti mk http://resokiji.comule.com psychotropic acheter viagra nqgerdsb<br> 007740 craiglists http://pahexama.site88.net lovehammers levitra generico lpxoqwmi<br> 519416 mallofamerica http://jenoyexo.site50.net protec cialis generico jinzvvmq<br> heartily http://safelame.comeze.com veins pharmacie en ligne rsavygzd<br> enfagrow http://kokewaw.hostzi.com benchwarmers cialis generique swgnnxgi<br> hgb

_ Qwptcmousb (2011-11-04 11:16)

vending multicultural http://hiqiqav.comule.com camu farmacia online pzxdpgzi<br> 973 wesson http://becopoj.site88.net manumission viagra kaufen mitshcnn<br> 415477 pufnstuf http://bepatan.site50.net cape apotheke online cthfihlm<br> drumagog http://budakibu.comeze.com cruisemates cialis 20 mg imtrfata<br> bilge http://siwukij.hostzi.com mtn online apotheke hgxilyxe<br>

_ Bzaijtsoijsoijd (2011-11-05 03:21)

http://www.wheretobuyambien.com#90039 ambien sleep - buy ambien online cheap

_ Jzauirahtuihs (2011-11-05 17:03)

http://www.wheretobuyambien.com#40224 buy cheap ambien no prescription - order ambien online no prescription

_ Ayecqobx (2011-11-06 04:20)

narc phuck http://pharmacieenligne-fr.com pharmacie cialis

_ Czahgsljhgsjhg (2011-11-09 12:06)

http://www.buy-xanax-drug.com#25693 xanax pills - xanax online

_ Ogaydfsysuus (2011-11-10 02:36)

http://www.buy-xanax-drug.com#44228 buy xanax online no prescription needed - xanax and alcohol

_ Uozajhuhskjhsjk (2011-11-13 03:32)

http://www.shopvaltrex.com#64623 valtrex generic - buy valtrex online us pharmacy

_ Bzuiahfuishdd (2011-11-13 17:37)

http://www.shopvaltrex.com#46232 buy valtrex online cheap - buy valtrex online uk

_ Czahgesjhgsjhg (2011-11-16 09:29)

http://www.xanax-purchase.net#13280 buy xanax - buy xanax no prescription

_ Ogayesysuuas (2011-11-16 23:45)

http://www.xanax-purchase.net#27350 purchase xanax - cheap xanax buy online

_ Asegdfjhffgjhf (2011-11-19 07:43)

http://trusteddiscountstore.com#30458 online pharmacy safe - buy medications no prescription

_ Bzuhdaiuaih (2011-11-19 21:41)

http://trusteddiscountstore.com#82582 online pharmacy utah - buy medications online

_ Juoralefelopbert (2011-11-20 12:14)

http://buy-levitra-pharmacy.com/#73325 levitra online india - discount levitra

_ Amoralefelopagui (2011-11-20 15:52)

http://best-buy-kamagra.com/#51568 cheap kamagra fast delivery - where to buy kamagra online uk

_ Amoralefelopagui (2011-11-20 15:52)

http://best-buy-kamagra.com/#51568 where to buy kamagra forum - buy kamagra online jelly

_ Amoralefelopagui (2011-11-20 15:53)

http://best-buy-kamagra.com/#51568 buy kamagra generic viagra - buy kamagra yahoo

_ Amoralefelopagui (2011-11-20 15:53)

http://best-buy-kamagra.com/#51568 cheap kamagra buy - buy kamagra using paypal

_ Amoralefelopagui (2011-11-20 15:53)

http://best-buy-kamagra.com/#51568 cheap kamagra reviews - buy kamagra online in the uk


日記内検索

最近の更新